Concept

Quality factor — where it appears

A resonance's sharpness: its centre frequency divided by its bandwidth, written Q. It is also a settling time in disguise, because a resonance of Q takes about Q over pi cycles to build from rest, which is how long an instrument that fills up takes to speak.

Named by 15 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Which partials of a natural horn can be lipped into tune. Every partial of the natural series against the nearest note of twelve equal, in cents, with the band the player's lips can actually move it drawn around each one. The band is ±23.1 cents, computed from the Q-weighted mean of a bore at Q 40 and lips at Q 12 rather than chosen. 4 of the first 16 partials fall outside it: 7, 11, 13, 14. The worst is the 11th at -48.7 cents, which would need lips of Q 38 to reach — comparable with the bore's own, at which point the bore has stopped deciding the pitch at all.

The partial the lips cannot reach

A wind instrument plays between its valve's preferred frequency and its bore's, which suggested that the natural trumpet's notorious eleventh partial would therefore turn out to be a statement about the lips. It is not. Run the same Q-weighted mean over the whole series and the lips can move that partial twenty-three cents, which is a quarter of what it needs — and the Q that would fix it is the Q at which the bore stops choosing the note.

tuning · Air column

Three ways a note starts, on one pair of axes. Every instrument in this collection, with how long its note takes to speak measured twice: across, in periods of the note itself; up, in milliseconds. The three clusters are three different pieces of physics. A wind instrument accumulates energy in a resonance, so its wait is the resonance's Q — 27, 26, 26, 19, 37 periods here. A bowed string is at full amplitude the moment Helmholtz motion begins and what takes time is the bow reaching a force inside Schelleng's window, which is 3.0, 3.8, 5.1, 7.6 periods. A plucked or struck string is at full amplitude at once and the only duration in it is the exciter's own contact, under a tenth of a period. The two axes do not agree: the slowest instrument in milliseconds is an alto saxophone at 159, and in periods it is an alto saxophone at 37.

A note takes a number of periods to speak

Two separate accounts stopped at the same object and said so. A wind instrument's note takes as long to arrive as its resonance takes to build, and that time is the resonance's Q divided by its frequency — so the number of periods is the Q and has no pitch in it, while the number of milliseconds does. The two readings order the instruments differently, and both orderings are wanted.

instruments · Onset time

Up a trumpet, the two clocks disagree. Every impedance peak of a trumpet, with the settling time each implies. The Q rises up the ladder and so does the frequency, and the settling time is their ratio — so in milliseconds the wait falls from 153 at the C♯2 to 24 at the B5, while in periods it rises from 11 to 24. Both curves are monotone and they point opposite ways, which means a player going up the instrument gets notes that arrive sooner and take longer in their own terms. Nothing here is a measurement of an instrument: it is the transmission-line solve of a trumpet-shaped bore, whose peak Qs are sensitive to how finely the sweep is sampled at about five per cent.

The higher note speaks sooner and takes longer

Up a brass instrument the settling time in milliseconds falls by a factor of seven and the settling time in periods rises by a factor of three. Both curves are read off the same impedance sweep, both are monotone over most of the compass, and they point in opposite directions — so the slowest note of the instrument depends entirely on which clock is used to time it.

tuning · Onset time

A family resemblance in the heights

Trumpet, horn and trombone differ in length by a factor of two and a half, so their frequency series cannot be laid over one another. Their impedance peaks agree to three decibels in height and to thirty per cent in Q, peak for peak, and the agreement improves with peak number. An earlier essay inferred that a family has one voice because it has one filter; the solver can now be asked directly.

instruments · Bore profile

trumpet: what the cup does to every peak. Each impedance peak of a trumpet drawn twice: as the bare bore, and with its own catalogue mouthpiece in front of the throat. The bare heights fall monotonically, from 19.2 at the pedal to 1.96 at the top of the series, which is what a tube does. The fitted heights do not: they fall to 5.4 at E♭6 and rise again to 30.1 at E♭5, giving the instrument a maximum of support in the middle of its compass that the tube alone has nowhere. The dashed line is the mouthpiece's popping frequency, 642 hertz — the note the cup sounds when it is slapped on the palm — and the maximum sits beside it.

What a cup does to the support

The mouthpiece's job was settled four essays ago and settled in cents: it decides which harmonic each mode is. Measured instead in the currency a player buys one in — how hard the note pushes back, and how narrowly it holds its pitch — the cup does something else entirely. It multiplies the support in the written register by about five, and it puts a ceiling on the instrument that the bell had not put there.

instruments · Bore profile

Settling and being heard are not the same quantity. Across, how long the instrument takes to reach its steady amplitude, computed from its own physics — a resonance's Q, a bow's capture, an exciter's contact. Up, how long after its physical onset a listener places the note, computed from the measured shape of its envelope. Five instruments both accounts hold. The diagonal is where they would agree and nothing is on it. The ratio between them runs from 0.10 to 6.6, a factor of 69, and it sorts perfectly by mechanism: about 6.6 for a struck or plucked string, 2.2 for a bowed one, and about 0.15 for a wind. Ordering the five by each measure changes the place of 3 of them, and the one that moves furthest is the violin — third slowest to settle and the last to be heard.

A note starts twice

One account computes how long an instrument takes to settle, from its own physics. Another computes how long after its onset a listener places a note, from the shape of its envelope. Both come out in milliseconds and neither has ever been shown the other. Paired on the five instruments they share, the ratio between them spans a factor of sixty-nine and sorts perfectly by mechanism — and the violin is third slowest to settle and the last to be heard.

rhythm · Onset time

A straight mute where its corks put it, and the annulus left over. The last 220 millimetres of a trumpet's bell, drawn to scale in radius and in length, with a straight mute in it. The mute is a cone 150 mm long running from 35 mm across at the tip to 105 at the base, and it is pushed in until its clearance is the cork's 3.0 mm — which stops it 63 mm inside the rim. The sound goes past it through the annulus between cone and wall, and the narrowest place in that annulus is 393 square millimetres, 59 mm in, which is 27 per cent of the bell's own section there. The lower curve is that annulus turned into the only thing a transmission line cares about: the radius of a round tube of the same area, which falls to 11.2 mm at the throat and recovers to 53 at the rim.

The resonator at the far end

A cup at the throat owns the top of a brass instrument and puts a ceiling on it. A straight mute is a second closure at the other end of the same air column, and the prediction written down before it was computed was that it would push that ceiling further down. It does the opposite: the ceiling goes from C6 to E♭6, and it goes there by reviving exactly the resonances the cup had killed.

instruments · Bore profile

Four bells on one tube, and the series each of them supports. The same 1.48-metre trumpet bore, drawn to scale, with its mouth opened from 32 millimetres across to 280 — a factor of 8.8 in radius and everything else held. Beside each is the frequency past which its flare stops reflecting, computed from the geometry: 403 Hz, 1212 Hz, 2945 Hz, 7303 Hz. That boundary moves by a factor of 18. The resonances underneath it barely move at all — the fourth peak sits at 409, 421, 428, 432 hertz across all four.

The mouth that decides nothing

Twelve figures across six earlier essays draw a trumpet with a 124-millimetre bell, and not one of them draws any other. Opened from 32 millimetres across to 280, the bell's own boundary moves by a factor of eighteen and almost nothing else moves at all: the instrument's registration, the sharpness of its notes in the written register, and where it runs out are all within a semitone of themselves. The reason is that the resonances are held by the walls, and a bell cannot reach them.

instruments · Bore profile

A clarinet's partials, each on its own resonance. The 8 partials of the clarinet's chalumeau D that ride an impedance peak, each building toward its steady amplitude as 1 − exp(−t/τ) with τ = Q/πf from that peak's own Q. The time constants run from 11.9 milliseconds to 64.5, so the partials do not arrive at different times — they all begin the instant the reed does — and what differs is how fast each approaches its final level. The horizontal bars are how far apart the first and last are at three criteria: 5.5 ms at 10 per cent, 36.4 ms at 50 per cent, 121.0 ms at 90 per cent. A twenty-millisecond asynchrony is the threshold for hearing a partial out of a note, and this note crosses it at 32 per cent of steady amplitude — so whether a blown note's onset cue is unanimous or divided is decided entirely by how far along a partial has to be before it counts as having started.

A blown note does not start late, it starts slowly

Computing the onset cue removed a free parameter and turned out to be unanimous, and it predicted that a wind instrument would put it back, because a blown note's partials arrive over tens of milliseconds. They do — 121 on a clarinet — and it is not an asynchrony: every partial begins the instant the reed does and they differ in rate, not in time. Read at a tenth of the steady amplitude the spread is 5.5 milliseconds against a threshold of twenty, so the cue is still unanimous, and the missing number is no longer the exchange rate but the criterion.

perception · Auditory scene

Three impedances meet at the bowing point and only one is in the way. Every impedance at the contact between a violin bow and a violin's strings, on one logarithmic axis in kilograms per second. The four strings run from 0.19 on the E to 0.34 on the G. The hair ribbon's TRANSVERSE impedance, across its own length, is 0.59 — 1.7 to 3.2 times the strings', which is comparable and is the number expected earlier to matter. It lies perpendicular to the string's own motion, because the bow is drawn ACROSS the string and the hair therefore runs along the direction the string vibrates in; what it is in the path of is the bow force. The impedance that does lie along the string's motion is the ribbon's LONGITUDINAL one, 11.4, which is 19 times the transverse and 34 to 61 times the strings'. A point load of that size against the 2Zc a string offers reflects 94.4 per cent of an arriving corner, so the fixed bowing point every earlier figure has assumed is right to within 5.6 per cent on the G string.

The hair runs the wrong way

Eight earlier essays treat the bow as a contact and the string as the object, and the last of them asked what the bow's own impedance does at the point of contact. It has three, and the one that is comparable to the string's — 0.59 kilograms per second against 0.19 to 0.34 — lies at right angles to the direction the string moves in. The one that lies along it is thirty-four times the string's, which is why a fixed bowing point has been the right assumption all along; and it stops being right at one partial in the middle of the instrument's range.

instruments · Bowed string

What a slow start costs a trumpet, in its own settling time. The amplitude of a trumpet's A4 resonance — the 4th impedance peak, of Q 37, time constant 27.1 milliseconds — driven from rest by a pressure that rises over 10, 40, 80, 140 milliseconds, against the step every earlier figure has assumed. The step reaches 90 per cent of its final amplitude in 62.5 milliseconds. A ramp of 140 takes 157.8, which is 95.3 more — and that excess is 68 per cent of the ramp's own length. Across the whole range a player works in the excess is a little over half the ramp: 0.52, 0.56, 0.61, 0.68 at 10, 40, 80, 140 milliseconds. So the tongued attack is not something added to the note. It is the step, which is what has been computed all along, and what has a price is its absence.

What the tongue actually removes

The question this essay was written against asked for an impulse: a tongued attack, a martelé stroke and a struck key all deliver one before the steady drive begins. The arithmetic refuses the framing. A tongue release does carry energy at the note's own frequency, and it is worth 0.17 milliseconds on a trumpet against a settling time of 62 — capped at about 1.13 over the resonance's Q. What articulation is worth is the ramp it removes, and that is about half the ramp's own length: 44 milliseconds, and very nearly the same 44 on every wind instrument in the collection.

rhythm · Onset time $The census with the criterion moved under it. Every instrument's speaking time in milliseconds, against the fraction of the steady amplitude counted as speaking. The criterion is in the wind instruments alone: a resonance takes −ln(1−p)·Q/(πf) to reach a fraction p, so those lines rise across the whole picture, while a bow's capture and an exciter's contact contain no criterion at all and are flat. Every earlier figure sits at 0.9, where the wind instruments are the slowest things in the collection by a factor of 20.5. At 0.05 they are the fastest: a violin's G3 string is the slowest at 15.5 milliseconds and a trumpet takes 1.4. The three clusters cross at a criterion between 0.18 and 0.39, which is inside the range the perceptual measurements work in — their three named criteria are 15 decibels below peak, 6 decibels below peak, and ninety per cent — and the settling figures have only ever used the third of them.$

Read at two different heights

Ten placements of these figures, one value: the settling criterion is nine tenths in every one of them, and nothing is measured behind it. It is a multiplicative constant only inside the mechanism that has it — a bow's capture and an exciter's contact contain no criterion at all — so moving it rescales one of three clusters against two that stand still. The most-quoted number here, a factor of sixty-nine between the instrument's account and the listener's, is 5.9 at the criterion the listener's own measurements use, and the ordering an earlier essay was written about does not exist below a fifth.

perception · Onset time

What a stopped tube tuned to the fundamental does to a marimba bar's partials. Power radiated from the mouth of a 311 millimetre stopped tube of 56 millimetre bore, tuned so that its first resonance is the bar's fundamental at 262 hertz, plotted against multiples of that fundamental and referred to what it does at the fundamental itself. Its quality factor there is 80. A stopped tube resonates at the odd multiples and presents an infinite input impedance — a rigid lid — at the even ones, so a partial's fate is decided by the parity of the ratio the arch put it on. The bar's own partials are marked: 1 at 0.0 decibels, 4.00 at -38.5 decibels, 9.03 at -13.1 decibels.

The tube shuts on the partial the arch placed

A stopped tube tuned to a bar's fundamental resonates at every odd multiple of it and presents a rigid lid — an infinite input impedance — at every even one. A xylophone's arch puts its second partial on 3, which is a resonance, and the tube passes it within five decibels. A marimba's puts it on 4, which is an antiresonance, and the tube takes it thirty-eight decibels down. Same tube, opposite answers, and the difference is parity.

instruments · Struck bar

Four throats on one instrument, drawn to scale. 4 bores 148 centimetres long, drawn to scale in radius and length, differing only in the radius of the tube itself — 6.0, 9.6, 14.0, 22.0 millimetres across at the throat. The mouth is held at 124 millimetres, which is what a maker changing a leadpipe actually does. A consequence is that the flare ratio falls from 20.7 to 5.6 and the bell's own boundary with it, from 5906 hertz to 1158. Beside each is the fourth resonance and how sharp it is: 427 Hz at Q 23, 428 Hz at Q 34, 427 Hz at Q 44, 421 Hz at Q 51. The notes move by 27 cents across the whole sweep and the sharpness rises by a factor of 2.2.

The throat that decides both

Eight earlier essays draw a tube eleven millimetres across and none of them draws another. Opened from six millimetres to twenty-two, it does exactly what was predicted to the loss in the walls — and it moves the radiation loss three times further, in the opposite direction, and monotonically, which the bell does not. So the two ends of a brass instrument do not divide the two losses between them. One end owns one loss and both ends own the other.

instruments · Bore profile

Where a bar and its pipe stop being two things. The two normal modes of a bar and a resonator tuned to it, against how strongly they are coupled, at 262 hertz. Below a threshold the pair has one frequency and two different decay rates — the pale curves, which are the damping splitting rather than the pitch — and above it the frequencies separate. The threshold is exact and it is not a matter of degree: it is where the coupling rate equals half the difference between the two damping rates, which for a bar of Q 197 against a tube of Q 80 is a coupling of 0.37 per cent. A marimba's own coupling is 0.62 per cent — 1.67 times the threshold, and not free: it is fixed by how much louder the tube makes the note, since the coupling that splits the pair is the coupling that carries the energy out. So the resonator model's assumption that the tube is a filter downstream of the bar is wrong at middle C, and it is wrong by less than a factor of two.

A bar and its pipe are one object

Three earlier essays treat a marimba's resonator as a filter the bar's output passes through, and both of them said in their own caveats that the coupling was not modelled. It is here, and the debt was right: the coupling is 1.67 times the threshold at which the pair acquires two frequencies instead of two decay rates, so the tube is not downstream of anything. Every consequence of that is smaller than the peaks it would have to be seen between.

instruments · Struck bar

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Impedance Resonance Brass Attack transient Bore Transient Damping Helmholtz motion Onset Radiation efficiency Cutoff Air column

All concepts