Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Theme

The comma that will not close

Twelve fifths do not equal seven octaves. Every tuning system in history is a different decision about where to hide the difference.
Twelve fifths do not make seven octaves. Pitch drawn as a spiral: one turn is one octave, so a note's angle is its pitch class and its radius is how high it has climbed. Twelve pure fifths wind round 7 times and a little further, finishing 23.46 cents past seven octaves — the Pythagorean comma. Nothing in the chain closes that gap; it is what a tuning has to absorb, hide or spread. Pitch and tuning

Twelve fifths and seven octaves, which are not the same thing

Stack twelve perfect fifths and the note that arrives should be the one seven octaves up. It is sharp by about a quarter of a semitone, and the whole history of tuning is a set of decisions about what to do with that.

 How far each system sits from equal temperament. Deviation from equal temperament, in cents, for each degree of the chromatic scale. Zero is equal temperament by definition; the just major third is about fourteen cents flat of it and the Pythagorean major third about eight cents sharp. Pitch and tuning

Where to hide the comma, which is the only real question

Four tuning systems, four different places to put an error that cannot be removed. Each one is coherent, each was standard somewhere, and the choice between them decided what music could be written.

 The chain of fifths in quarter-comma meantone. The fifths laid end to end as the chain they are. The bar under each shows how far that fifth departs from a pure three-to-two, and one of them — G♯ to D♯, the 12th link, where the chain is forced to close — is the wolf, at 35.7 cents. Pitch and tuning

The wolf at the end of the chain

Put all the tuning error into one interval and eleven others become perfect. The twelfth becomes a howl, and for two centuries keyboards were built that way on purpose.

 The syntonic comma on the lattice. Pitch classes reached by multiplying by three — a fifth, one step east — and by five — a major third, one step north. Two routes to the same note name arrive at different pitches, and the syntonic comma is the size of that disagreement: 21.51 cents. Pitch and tuning

A second comma, arriving by a different road

Four pure fifths ought to land on a pure major third, two octaves up. They miss by 21.5 cents — a different gap from the one twelve fifths leave, produced by a different route, and the two are not the same size.

 Key character in Werckmeister III. The twelve major keys in circle-of-fifths order, each with a bar as long as its major third is sharp of a pure 5:4. The bars run from 3.9 to 21.5 cents, so the keys genuinely differ. Pitch and tuning

Keys that had characters, and could be measured

Eighteenth-century writers described E flat major as devotional and F sharp major as harsh, and modern readers file it under synaesthesia. On the instruments those writers used, the difference between the two keys was seventeen cents of third, and that is a quantity.

 Every equal division from 5 to 60, and how wrong it is. For each number of equal steps in the octave, how far its best fifth and its best major third fall from the pure ratios, in cents. The divisions people have actually used are the ones with small errors in both, and no other criterion was applied to pick them out. Pitch and tuning

Nineteen, thirty-one and fifty-three

Divide the octave into a different number of equal parts and different problems disappear. Which ones vanish is not a matter of taste — it can be computed from the prime factors of the intervals, and each division makes a different decision.

 220 Hz against 223 Hz. Two tones 3 hertz apart, added. The rapid oscillation is their average; the slow swelling is their difference, heard as 3 beats a second and used by every tuner who has ever worked by ear. Intervals and chords

Beats are arithmetic that anybody can hear

Two tones a few hertz apart swell and fade at exactly their difference. It is the most direct evidence available that the ear does sums on what reaches it, and it is how every instrument in the world gets tuned.

 The circle of fifths. The twelve pitch classes arranged so that each is a fifth above the last. Keys next to each other differ by one sharp or flat, which is why the notes of a key form a contiguous arc rather than a scattering. Scales and modes

Keys are neighbours, and the map is computed

Two keys a fifth apart share six of their seven notes. That single fact generates the circle of fifths, the key signatures, the shape of nearly every modulation, and the sense that some keys are far away.

 The seven chords of a key, by distance from home. Each triad of the major scale placed at a radius equal to how far its voices must move from the tonic chord. The chords that feel closest to home are the ones that are closest, in the plain arithmetic sense. Harmony and voice leading

A progression is a path, and the map can be drawn

Chords in a key are not a list. They sit at measurable distances from home, and a progression is a walk across that space — which explains why some sequences feel like journeys and others like wandering.

 Where a progression in pure ratios ends up. A short chord sequence taken in exact whole-number ratios, with the running difference from equal temperament measured in cents. The sequence returns to its starting chord and the pitch does not, which is the comma arriving in ordinary music. Harmony and voice leading

The progression that never comes home

Just intonation is usually said to fail because a keyboard has only twelve keys. That is not the reason. Take one of the commonest chord sequences in tonal music, play every chord in exact whole-number ratios, and it arrives back on its starting chord a syntonic comma flat — on any instrument, including a voice.

 The smallest audible difference, and what has to clear it. The difference limen for frequency, converted from Wier, Jesteadt and Green's 1977 fit into cents, against the intervals and commas the rest of these essays argue about. Anything drawn below the curve is a quantity nobody can hear as a change of pitch; anything well above it is a quantity a listener can be asked about. The limen is for pure tones, successive, with trained listeners — the most favourable case there is, and therefore the right one to test a claim against. Perception and the listener

How small a difference is audible

Every essay here about tuning has assumed a listener who can hear the difference between two systems. The assumption has a number: about five cents in the middle of the range. It clears the two commas fourfold and it does not clear the schisma at all, which sorts the whole subject of tuning into the part that is about music and the part that is about arithmetic.

 Where one interval stops being itself. Identification as a function of interval size: the probability that a listener names each category, modelled as a logistic with the boundary positions and sharpness a study reports. One category's share falls from three-quarters to one-quarter over 24 cents, against the 100 that separate adjacent categories — so the change of mind happens in 24% of the gap and the rest of it is not in doubt at all. That is what makes a mistuned third a third that is out, rather than a different interval. Perception and the listener

The chord is still major, and that is why temperament works

A major third can be seventeen cents wrong and still be a major third. That tolerance is not a failure of hearing — it is the reason the whole subject of tuning is a discussion rather than a catastrophe. Every temperament ever proposed moves intervals around inside their categories, and the one thing none of them may do is push one across a boundary.

 The worst interval in each open chord, before and after the best possible compensation. For each shape, the largest departure of any interval from the just interval its name implies, in cents. Before compensation the worst is 15.6 cents; after a search over per-string saddle compensation it is 15.6. The search has six numbers to fix eight shapes with, and on this measure it finds nothing worth changing — because what is being measured is almost entirely equal temperament's own thirds, and a saddle moves a length rather than a temperament. Pitch and tuning

A guitar cannot be in tune

Three errors land on the same instrument — equal temperament's own thirds, the sharpening that comes from pressing a string down to a fret, and the fact that the only correction available is one length per string. Searching over every setting a luthier could choose leaves a worst-case error of about fifteen cents, and most of what is left is the temperament, which no saddle can reach.

 Every keyboard temperament before 1800, on one line. The fifth's departure from pure against the major third's, for a temperament that narrows every fifth by the same amount. The relation is a straight line — a third is four fifths — so the systems that are usually presented as rival schemes are points on one continuum, and the parameter that indexes them is a single number. Pitch and tuning

A fraction of a comma

The tuning systems of three centuries are usually presented as rival schemes with names and dates. They are points on a line. Narrow every fifth by the same fraction of a comma and both errors that matter are linear in that fraction — and the system named as the break with the tradition turns out to be a member of it, at one part in eleven.

 The same total, distributed differently. The departure of each of the twelve major thirds from a pure 5:4, one row per temperament, keys ordered round the circle of fifths. The totals are equal — every closing temperament's twelve thirds add to 4800 cents — so what a temperament chooses is not how much error there is but which keys carry it. Pitch and tuning

What a temperament cannot do

Add up the twelve major thirds of any keyboard tuning whose chain of fifths closes and the answer is 4,800 cents. Every time, in every system, before a single fifth has been chosen. So no temperament has ever made the average third less wrong than any other one, and four hundred years of argument were about a distribution rather than about accuracy.

 The comma is conserved; only the place it is paid is chosen. Every policy available to a continuous-pitch ensemble on one line: drift per circuit along the bottom, worst mistuned interval up the side. The line is straight and its intercepts are fixed, because the 4 moves of the pump have to absorb 21.51 cents between them however they are shared. Spreading it evenly puts 5.377 cents on each interval — the same narrowing quarter-comma meantone applies to every fifth. Harmony and voice leading

Somebody has to pay the comma

A choir has no frets and no keys, so it can tune every chord exactly — and a common progression sung that way arrives a comma flat, every circuit. The freedom a keyboard lacks turns out to be a freedom about where the error goes rather than whether there is one, and the two costs always add to the same number.

 Nine commas, and the line under which none of them matters. Each named comma at its true size in cents, against the difference limen of 3.87 cents at 500 Hz — the smallest change of frequency a listener can detect, computed from the same formula the perception essays use. One comma falls below it, and it is the only gap in the subject that no tuning system has to do anything about. Pitch and tuning

A comma under the threshold

Eight pure fifths taken downwards arrive at a major third 1.95 cents flat of a perfect 5:4. That gap has a name and a history, and it is the only one in the subject nobody has ever had to hide — it is under the smallest difference a listener can detect, which makes a chain of untempered fifths a source of almost-just thirds and makes one eighteenth-century tuning nearly free.

 Which traditions make the requirements that produce a comma. Four requirements and five tuning traditions. A comma is what is left over when a scale is generated by fifths, the octave is kept pure, and the chain has to close so that any degree can be a tonic — so a tradition that declines any one of them has no comma to hide. The best fifth each system actually contains is printed beside it, because declining a requirement has its own price. Scales and modes

Where the chain was never closed

Eleven earlier essays treat the comma as a fact about music. It is a fact about three requirements — that the scale is built from fifths, that the octave stays pure, and that the chain closes so any degree can be a tonic — and most of the world's tuning traditions decline at least one of them. What they pay instead is computable, and it is paid somewhere else entirely.

 How far a chain of fifths is from closing, after each number of fifths. The distance from a whole number of octaves after each number of pure fifths, in cents, out to 60. It is never zero, because a fifth is 3/2 and no power of 3 is a power of 2. The running minima are 1, 2, 5, 12, 41, 53 fifths, and the residue at each is that division's comma: 23.46 cents at 12, 19.84 cents at 41, 3.62 cents at 53. A 3-against-2 polyrhythm asked the same question closes exactly and at once — 3 pulses of the 3 are 2 of the 2, to the last microsecond — because 3/2 is a ratio of whole numbers and log2(3/2) is not. Pitch and tuning

A comma is a polyrhythm that never closes

Seven earlier essays have rested on a common grid. Two cycles have one when their ratio is a ratio of whole numbers, and the fifth against the octave is not — provably, from unique factorisation. So there is no grid, no composite and no least common multiple, and what is left over instead is the sequence 2, 5, 12, 41, 53 with a comma attached to each.

 The sizes a chain of a pure fifth will make. Chains of a pure fifth of two to 12 notes, each folded into one octave and drawn on a 1200-cent line. A chain has exactly two step sizes at 2, 3, 5, 7, 12 notes and three or more at every other size in this range. The five-note and seven-note cases are the chain's pentatonic and its diatonic set, and they are neighbours in a series rather than two separate facts. Scales and modes

The only sizes a fifth will make

Stack pure fifths and fold them into an octave, and at almost every number of notes the result has three or more different step sizes. At 2, 3, 5, 7, 12, 17 and 29 it has exactly two — and at no other size below thirty. The pentatonic and the diatonic set are not two discoveries. They are neighbours in one series, and it is the comma's series.

 A note sung at 440 Hz, drawn in cents. Deviation from the notated pitch against time, for a vibrato of ±71 cents at 6.0 cycles a second — Seashore's and Prame's measured values, which agree. The note is 142 cents wide, and the shaded bands across the middle are the syntonic comma at 21.5 cents, the Pythagorean comma at 23.5 cents, the difference limen at 440 Hz at 4.0 cents. The pitch a listener reports is near the middle of the excursion rather than at either edge — and not exactly at the middle either: because cents are logarithmic and frequency is not, the mean frequency of this trace sits 0.73 cents above the centre line. Pitch and tuning

A note that is never at its pitch

Eleven essays in this field argue about differences of one to twenty-four cents. An ordinary operatic vibrato is a hundred and forty cents wide and completes six excursions a second, so every one of those distinctions fits inside a single sung note several times over — and the beat rate a tuner would null passes through zero eleven times a second.

 A wind instrument is a thermometer, and a string is not. Cents from the pitch at 20 degrees, against the temperature of the air inside a wind instrument and of a steel string, computed from the speed of sound as 343.2 metres a second times the square root of absolute temperature, and from a string's tension falling by Young's modulus times the expansion coefficient per degree. The wind slope is 2.95 cents a degree at 20 degrees, so 0.0 cents at 20, 11.7 cents at 24, 23.3 cents at 28, 34.7 cents at 32. The Pythagorean comma is reached at 28.1 degrees — 8.1 degrees of warming, which a wind instrument does from breath alone within a few minutes. The string goes the other way, 36 cents flat at 34 degrees, so the gap between the two sections opens at 5.4 cents a degree. Pitch and tuning

A wind instrument is a thermometer

Pitch goes as the square root of absolute temperature, so a warming clarinet sharpens by about three cents a degree and passes a Pythagorean comma after eight. The strings beside it go flat as they warm. Nobody chose either number, no temperament addresses either of them, and together they are twice the size of the discrepancy this whole field is named after.

 How far each system sits from equal temperament. Deviation from equal temperament, in cents, for each degree of the chromatic scale. Zero is equal temperament by definition; the just major third is about fourteen cents flat of it and the Pythagorean major third about eight cents sharp. Pitch and tuning

The note that is sharp because of where it goes

Eleven essays here have tuned notes against other notes sounding at the same time. A melodic line makes the opposite demand of the same note. In C major the leading note wants to be 1088 cents if the argument is vertical — a pure third above the dominant — and 1110 if it is horizontal, because a leading note is a note that is about to arrive somewhere and performers narrow the step. The two answers differ by 21.5 cents, which is a syntonic comma exactly, and no keyboard has ever been able to hold both.

 The chain of fifths in quarter-comma meantone. The fifths laid end to end as the chain they are. The bar under each shows how far that fifth departs from a pure three-to-two, and one of them — G♯ to D♯, the 12th link, where the chain is forced to close — is the wolf, at 35.7 cents. Intervals and chords

The same distance, under two names

Four hundred cents is a major third or a diminished fourth, and on a keyboard nothing in the sound distinguishes them. An earlier essay was about the boundary between two categories; this is about two categories at one acoustic value, and the surprise is where the ambiguity comes from. In quarter-comma meantone a major third is 386 cents and a diminished fourth is 427 — two names, two pitches, forty-one cents apart. Equal temperament collapsed them, and what a listener now supplies from context used to be in the sound.

 Where the two spellings meet, and where they cross. G♯ minus A♭ against the fraction of a comma each fifth is narrowed by — twelve fifths against seven octaves, and nothing else in the calculation. In Pythagorean tuning G♯ is 23.46 cents ABOVE A♭; in quarter-comma meantone it is 41.06 cents BELOW it; the two spellings coincide at 0.09090 of a comma, which is what equal temperament is. A page that distinguishes the two names is exact in every tuning on this line except one point on it, and at that point it is wrong by 0.0014 cents rather than by nothing, because one eleventh is not quite the crossing. Pitch and tuning

Two names for one key

A keyboard has one key between G and A and the page has two names for it. That looks like redundancy and it is not: the two names are twelve fifths apart on a chain, and in every tuning anybody played before the nineteenth century they are two different pitches. The size of the difference is twelve fifths against seven octaves and nothing else — twenty-three cents one way in Pythagorean, forty-one the other way in meantone, and zero at exactly one point in between.

 How far equal temperament puts each interval's coincidence out. For each interval, the pair of partials it brings together and how many cents equal temperament mistunes that coincidence by. A fifth's third-against-second is out by 2 cents and a major third's fifth-against-fourth by 14 — so the same temperament that is inaudible on a fifth produces, at 220 hertz, a beat of 8.7 per second between two sections singing a third, with every singer in both of them perfectly in tune. Timbre and acoustics

A section against another section

The choir has been treated as a unison, and no choir sings only unisons. Two sections an interval apart beat between partials rather than between fundamentals — the third brings the fifth partial of one against the fourth of the other — and equal temperament puts that coincidence fourteen cents out. So two sections singing a tempered third beat at nearly nine per second with every singer in both of them perfectly in tune, and the same temperament is inaudible on a fifth.

 The beat rate between two sections, second by second. The 5th partial of the lower section against the 4th of the upper, over 256 pairs of voices each sweeping 100 cents 6 times a second with its own phase. The band is the tenth to the ninetieth percentile of the instantaneous rate and the line is the median. With no vibrato the whole thing would be one flat line at 8.7 hertz, which is what was computed earlier. With it, the pair is inside the beating band 20 per cent of the time and above it for the rest — so what a listener gets is neither a beat nor a roughness but an alternation between them at the vibrato rate. Intervals and chords

Sixteen sweeps against sixteen

Every intonation figure about the voice treats a singer as a frequency. A singer is a frequency being swept a hundred cents wide six times a second, and two sections singing an interval are two hundred and fifty-six pairs of sweeps. The beat rate between the partials the interval brings together stops being a number and becomes a function of time — and the pair spends four fifths of its time above the rate at which beating is beating at all.

 The ensemble agrees with itself more and more, about a pitch that is moving. Runs of 16 players each correcting toward the mean of their neighbours, with no term anywhere pulling them back to the note they were given, over 480 corrections. The shaded band is the root-mean-square displacement across all eight runs — the envelope a random walk has — and it grows from 0.84 cents a quarter of the way through to 2.01 at the end, which is the square-root growth a random walk has. Four individual runs are drawn inside it and the furthest of the eight over the top, ending at 4.16 cents. Meanwhile the spread AMONG the players falls from 2.8 cents to 0.5. A consensus with no anchor cannot hold a pitch, and it also cannot lose one quickly: a movement's worth of corrections is a few cents rather than the semitone unaccompanied choirs are said to fall by. Pitch and tuning

A consensus with nothing to hold it

Once the oboe has stopped, no reference is left in the room. Each player corrects toward what they hear around them, which is other players correcting toward them — and a consensus dynamic has a fixed point at every common value, so it pulls the ensemble together and nothing pulls it anywhere in particular. Simulated, the players' spread falls from 2.8 cents to 0.5 while the ensemble as a whole random-walks. The size is the result and it is small: two or three cents over a movement, which is a tenth of what unaccompanied choirs are said to lose.

 A string quartet's open strings are five keys of a Pythagorean keyboard. The five pitch classes a string quartet's open strings sound — C, G, D, A and E — laid out as the chain of fifths they are tuned along, outward from the A the ensemble is given, with each fifth pure. The bars give each string's departure from the same note on an equal-tempered keyboard: C −5.87 cents, G −3.91 cents, D −1.96 cents, A 0.00 cents, E +1.96 cents. Above, the strings each instrument owns: the violin G, D, A, E; the viola C, G, D, A; the cello the same four an octave lower. The cello's C2 is 0.221 hertz below the keyboard's, and the widest span of the chain, from the cello's C to the violin's E, is a Pythagorean third and two octaves, 21.5 cents wider than a just one. Pitch and tuning

The tuning a string quartet cannot change

A string quartet can put every stopped note wherever it likes, and it has five pitches it cannot move once the pegs are turned: the open strings C, G, D, A and E, tuned in pure fifths from the A it was given. That makes its only fixed tuning a five-key Pythagorean keyboard — the cello's C nearly six cents below a piano's, and every third two open strings can make a syntonic comma from just. Counted key by key, the clash is worst in G, C and F, the keys that use every open string, and absent from A and E.

 A tempered fifth is a beat a second on the violin and one in four and a half seconds on the cello. How fast each open fifth of a string quartet beats when it is narrowed by 1.955 cents, the narrowing that meets an equal-tempered keyboard. The beat is the lower string's third partial against the upper string's second, so it is proportional to the lower string's frequency. Cello C2–G2: 0.22 a second, one beat every 4.5 seconds; cello G2–D3: 0.33 a second, one beat every 3.0 seconds; cello D3–A3: 0.50 a second, one beat every 2.0 seconds; viola C3–G3: 0.44 a second, one beat every 2.3 seconds; viola G3–D4: 0.66 a second, one beat every 1.5 seconds; violin G3–D4: 0.66 a second, one beat every 1.5 seconds; violin D4–A4: 1.00 a second, one beat every 1.0 seconds; violin A4–E5: 1.49 a second, one beat every 0.7 seconds. The slowest, the cello's C2–G2, is 6.7 times slower than the violin's A4–E5. Pitch and tuning

The cello cannot hear its own tempering

Narrowing a quartet's fifths to meet a piano is one number, 1.96 cents a fifth, and it is a different beat on every string: once every two thirds of a second on the violin's A–E and once every four and a half seconds on the cello's C–G. Set by ear for two seconds a fifth, the violin's E lands within two thirds of a cent and the cello's C within 5.7 — which is as large as the Pythagorean error the tempering was meant to remove. The string whose tuning is most wrong is the string whose tuning is least certain, and a cellist tuning down the chain cannot tell pure from tempered.

 An unaccompanied quartet settles where its open strings put it. The average pitch of a quartet correcting toward itself over 480 corrections, in cents from the note it was given, averaged over 24 runs. With no pull from the open strings the ensemble random-walks, and the shaded band is how far: 3.7 cents root-mean-square by the end. With each open string pulling the notes that share its pitch class at a weight of 0.05, the ensemble settles at −0.97 cents in A major, against −1.01 from the open strings' weighted mean; −2.46 cents in C major, against −2.42 from the open strings' weighted mean; −2.53 cents in E♭ major, against −2.54 from the open strings' weighted mean. Pitch and tuning

An open string pulls the quartet flat

Once the tuning note has stopped, a quartet corrects toward itself and nothing holds its pitch. But four of its pitches do not move: the open strings, on a Pythagorean chain from C 5.9 cents flat to E 2.0 sharp, each ringing when a stopped note shares its pitch class. Give that sympathy a weight of a hundredth of a correction and it beats the random walk within a movement. The quartet settles flat in every major key — by 0.9 cents in E, 2.5 in C and 2.6 in A♭ — and in A♭ major the cellist's tuning scatter moves the whole ensemble by 1.7 cents.

 Four pure fourths and a pure third leave a comma on the top strings. Each of a guitar's six open strings, in cents from the note its own frets make, when the strings are tuned against each other three ways. fretted unisons: E2 +0.00, A2 +0.00, D3 +0.00, G3 +0.00, B3 +0.00, E4 +0.00. harmonics, pure third on G–B: E2 +0.00, A2 −1.96, D3 −3.91, G3 −5.87, B3 −19.55, E4 −21.51. harmonics, B from the low E's twelfth: E2 +0.00, A2 −1.96, D3 −3.91, G3 −5.87, B3 +1.96, E4 +0.00. Tuned with pure fourths and a pure third the high E closes two octaves 21.51 cents flat, a syntonic comma; taking the B from the low E's twelfth lands the high E exactly and moves the error into the third between the G and B strings. Pitch and tuning

A guitar tuned by harmonics hides a comma

A quartet's stopped notes go wherever its players put them, so its open strings can sit on a pure chain. A guitar's stopped notes are fixed by frets that are already an equal temperament, and its six open strings — four fourths and a third — close two octaves exactly a syntonic comma short when tuned pure, since (4/3)⁴·(5/4) is 4 × 80/81. Tuning by harmonics decides where the comma goes, not whether: a pure third puts it in the octaves of an open E major chord, 17.6 cents narrow; a B from the low E's twelfth puts it in the G–B third, 21.5 cents wide.

 One of these tunings has no comma to place. Five guitar tunings, each with every adjacent interval set to the pure ratio nearest the interval it spans, drawn as how far each string then sits from where the frets put it. standard, spanning 5–5–5–4–5 semitones, closes 21.5 cents short and spreads its strings over 21.5 cents; drop D, spanning 7–5–5–4–5 semitones, closes 17.6 cents short and spreads its strings over 19.6 cents; D A D G A D, spanning 7–5–5–2–5 semitones, closes exactly and spreads its strings over 3.9 cents; open G, spanning 5–7–5–4–3 semitones, closes exactly and spreads its strings over 15.6 cents; open D, spanning 7–5–4–3–5 semitones, closes exactly and spreads its strings over 15.6 cents. Standard tuning's four fourths and a third fall a syntonic comma short of two octaves, which is what was found earlier. D A D G A D's fifth, two fourths, a tone and a fourth multiply to exactly four — two octaves — so nothing has to be put anywhere. Pitch and tuning

One tuning has no comma to place

Standard guitar tuning is four fourths and a third, and tuned pure it closes two octaves exactly a syntonic comma short — so tuning by ear decides where the comma goes rather than whether. An open tuning replaces the interval list. D A D G A D's fifth, two fourths, a tone and a fourth multiply to exactly four, so its chain closes and there is nothing to place: its six strings sit within four cents of the frets. The open-chord tunings close too, and pay for it with one string fifteen cents flat — which every chord barred straight across inherits exactly, and which is why every such chord is precisely as pure as the open one.

 Which tuning a piece wants, and when the answer is one that has a name. Three short pieces, each a list of fretted chords with durations, scored by how far their intervals sit from just on average — and each played three ways: with every string on its fret, with every adjacent interval of the tuning set pure, and with all six strings free and searched. open G blues costs 5.74 cents on the frets, 0.00 on the pure chain and 0.00 at its own optimum; D A D G A D air costs 1.79 cents on the frets, 0.60 on the pure chain and 0.60 at its own optimum; standard song costs 5.97 cents on the frets, 13.80 on the pure chain and 2.05 at its own optimum. The two pieces whose tuning closes gain nothing from the search: the named tuning already is the optimum, to a thousandth of a cent. The piece in standard tuning, whose chain falls a syntonic comma short, gains 3.92 cents on a tuning that has no name. Pitch and tuning

A tuning is right for some chords and wrong for the rest

An earlier essay asked which tuning minimises a piece's total departure from just, and guessed the answer would be a few cents off a named one. Searched over all six strings, two of three pieces get back the tuning they were already in — because their chains close and there is nothing to improve. The third lands on a tuning nobody names, three and nine tenths of a cent better than anything a player would have tried, and it is not a compromise: two of its three chords are exactly just and the third is abandoned by thirteen cents.

 Counted in beats, the abandoned chord comes back sooner and by steps. The piece in standard tuning with its G major, open chord given more and more of the piece, searched twice: once minimising the mean departure from just in cents, once minimising the mean beat rate. The vertical axis is how far that chord sits from just at each optimum. Counted in cents it stays at 13.29 cents until it holds exactly 44 beats — the same as the rest of the piece — and then drops to zero in one step. Counted in beats it drops at 30.4 beats to 4.96, then at 47.4 beats to 3.91, then at 73.1 beats to 0.00 cents. At the piece's own 8 beats the two counts agree exactly: the corner does not move, and what the beats change is where the steps are. Pitch and tuning

Counting beats moves the price of a chord, not the tuning

The search that found a guitar piece's best tuning counted every cent of error alike, and the obvious objection is that a cent of a third beats faster than a cent of an octave. Counted in beats instead, every piece gets exactly the same tuning back. What changes is how much of the piece the abandoned chord has to hold before it is rescued — thirty beats instead of forty-four, arriving in three steps instead of one.

 Two shapes asking fifteen pairs of strings for different things. Every pair of the six strings, and the difference in cents between the two strings' offsets that would make the interval each shape puts on that pair exactly just. The piece's chords fall into two families that never disagree with themselves: E major, open and A major barred at 5 (44 beats), and G major, open (8 beats). They disagree on 13 of the 15 pairs: E2–A2 is asked for 1.96 and -13.69; E2–D3 is asked for 0.00 and 1.96; E2–G3 is asked for -13.69 and 0.00; E2–B3 is asked for 1.96 and -13.69; A2–D3 is asked for -1.96 and 15.64; A2–G3 is asked for -15.64 and 13.69; A2–E4 is asked for -1.96 and 13.69; D3–G3 is asked for -13.69 and -1.96; D3–B3 is asked for 1.96 and -15.64; D3–E4 is asked for 0.00 and -1.96; G3–B3 is asked for 15.64 and -13.69; G3–E4 is asked for 13.69 and 0.00; B3–E4 is asked for -1.96 and 13.69. The ring on each row is where the piece's cheapest tuning actually puts the pair. It sits on the first family's demand every time, which is what abandoning the other chord means: no weighting of the error can put a ring on two different places. Pitch and tuning

The chord a tuning gives up is a fingering

A guitar piece's best tuning makes two of its chords exactly just and abandons the third by thirteen cents, and no way of counting error — cents, beats, squared cents, or only the beats slow enough to hear — brings the third chord back. Fingered as a barre chord in the shape the other two already use, it comes back completely, and the whole piece is exactly just. The conflict was never between chords. It was between hands.

All themes