Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Spreading function — where it appears

The shape of the masked threshold a tone puts up around itself, across frequency. It is markedly asymmetric — a masker hides far more above itself than below — and the asymmetry grows with level, so a loud chord hides more of itself than a quiet one.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

What one tone hides, and in which direction. The masked threshold beside a tone masker: any probe below one of these curves is inaudible while the masker sounds. The frequency axis is in Bark, the scale on which the ear's filters are evenly spaced, so the pattern is a pair of straight lines. The upper slope is much shallower than the lower one and gets shallower still as the masker gets louder — masking spreads upward, not downward.

One sound hides another, and it hides upward

A tone can be made completely inaudible by a second tone that is nowhere near it in frequency, and the region it disappears into is lopsided. Masking spreads up the spectrum and barely down it, and the reach grows with the masker's level — so which line in an arrangement vanishes is a prediction, not a matter of taste.

perception · Masking A loud chord is a smaller chord. The share of a voicing's partials that stand above what the rest of it masks, and the share of its computed roughness that is between partials a listener actually has, from 30 decibels to 100. Both fall: 83 per cent of the partials survive at 30 decibels and 38 at 100, and the roughness share goes from 88 per cent to 67. The direction is the upward spread of masking, which grows faster than linearly with level: a loud partial masks a band above itself much wider than a quiet one does, so the chord's own top disappears into its own bottom. Two earlier essays are drawn at one level, and this is what they were holding.

A loud chord is a smaller chord

Two earlier essays hold the level fixed, and the level decides how much of a chord a listener is given. At thirty decibels twenty of a triad's twenty-four partials stand above what the rest of it masks; at a hundred, nine do. Every roughness figure until now counts partials that are in the score, and a partial the chord masks is not a partial the listener has.

harmony · Masking The roughest chord on the page is at C1 and the roughest one heard is at A♭2. One close triad at 70 decibels through 17 registers, with its roughness computed twice: over every partial in the score, and over only the partials that stand above what the chord itself masks. The written curve rises all the way down and its maximum is the lowest register drawn, C1, which is the low-interval rule as it has always been computed here. The delivered curve turns over at A♭2 and falls to nothing below A♭1: a close triad down there is not rough, because it is not arriving as a chord — 1 of its 24 partials survives at C1 and there is almost nothing left to beat against anything.

A low chord stops being rough by stopping being a chord

Every count of audible partials until now is of a chord at middle C, and the three registers it did compare span C3 to C5 — a third of the range a chord is written in. Move the same triad down and the count collapses: 79 per cent of its partials arrive at E3 and 4 per cent at C1. So the roughest chord on the page is the lowest one and the roughest chord a listener receives is at G2, and where that maximum sits moves nearly two octaves with the dynamic.

perception · Masking Scored the way these figures score it, a clarinet is the worst of the six. One close triad at 70 decibels through 17 registers, drawn once for each of the 6 spectra to hand. The score is the share of every partial written, which is the quantity the register figure published. pure 100 per cent at best, string 79 per cent at best, clarinet 54 per cent at best, reed 71 per cent at best, bell 52 per cent at best, organ 72 per cent at best. A clarinet's four even partials are twenty-eight decibels below its odd ones and are inaudible beside their own neighbours before any chord is built, so counting them in the denominator makes the spectrum that survives its own masking best look like the one that survives it worst.

A clarinet keeps what a string loses

Every masker, probe, chord, line and texture until now is eight partials falling as 1/n, and it was not even an option a placement could pass. Sweeping the six spectra to hand says the clarinet is the worst of them — 54 per cent of itself at best against a string's 79 — and that answer is an artefact of the score. Counted against what each note keeps on its own, the clarinet keeps 100 per cent where the string keeps 79, because its components stand a twelfth apart rather than an octave. The missing parameter was the spectrum; the second missing parameter was the denominator.

perception · Masking

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Critical bandwidthMaskingPartialRoughnessRegisterVoicingBark scaleDynamicsOrchestrationPerceptual codingSensory dissonanceSpectrum

All concepts