Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Simultaneity — where it appears

The set of pitches sounding at one instant, considered without any claim about which chord it is or what it is doing. Most simultaneities in an ordinary texture are not chords, which is why a progression has to be segmented out of one.

Named by 4 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Partial 3, mistuned by 3%. A 10-partial tone on 220 Hz with one partial treated differently from the rest. Mistuning it moves it off the harmonic grid by 3.0 per cent, which is 19.8 Hz — slow enough to be heard as a beat rather than as a separate pitch, and enough for the partial to be heard out of the note as a whistle of its own. An onset difference does the same to a partial that is exactly in tune.

What makes two partials one note

A note is a stack of ten or twenty simultaneous tones and is heard as one thing. The obvious explanation is that they are whole-number multiples of a fundamental — and the obvious explanation is not sufficient. Mistune one partial by three per cent and it leaves the note; give a perfectly harmonic partial a thirty-millisecond head start and it leaves too. Shared behaviour beats arithmetic.

timbre · Auditory scene Every delay, scored — a round and a tune that is not one. Mean Plomp-Levelt roughness of the simultaneities a tune makes against a copy of itself entering a whole number of bars later, for Frere Jacques and Twinkle, twinkle. The two do not overlap: the worst delay of the first is smoother than the best delay of the second. The model sees roughness and nothing else — no voice leading, no parallels, no distinction between a passing dissonance and a structural one.

A melody that can accompany itself

Whether a tune works as a round is decidable before anyone sings it. Score every simultaneity it makes against a delayed copy of itself, at every delay, with the roughness model already in use, and two nursery tunes separate completely — every delay of one is smoother than every delay of the other. What the scan does not do is pick out the entry the tradition uses, and that refusal is the most informative thing in it.

harmony · Voice-leading What a spread costs a chord. a major triad of 3 notes lasting 600 ms each, with the onsets spread by up to 320 ms. The upper line is the share of each note's length during which every note is sounding; the lower is the chord's roughness weighted by that share, since roughness is a property of two partials sounding at the same time. At a spread of 30 ms — the asynchrony at which a mistimed partial stops belonging to its note — the chord is still 89 per cent simultaneous. It stops being simultaneous at all at 300 ms, which is where the last note arrives after the first has finished.

The chord that is not played at once

Every chord until now starts its notes at the same instant, and no figure ever set the asynchrony to anything else. A spread chord is not a defective simultaneity: at forty milliseconds a triad of half-second notes is still eighty-seven per cent simultaneous, so it carries almost all its roughness, and it stops being a chord at all only when the last note arrives after the first has finished. What none of this can explain is the one thing every keyboard player knows — that a chord is rolled upward. The masking asymmetry that ought to explain it is 2.4 decibels at a close voicing, which is not enough.

intervals · The triad One envelope, and the three places a listener might be said to hear it. The amplitude envelope of a note with a 90 millisecond exponential attack, with the three criteria the literature offers drawn across it. The heard moment is 8.0 ms at the detection criterion, 28 ms at the perceptual-onset criterion and 94 ms at the perceptual-attack criterion. The physical onset is at zero on this axis and no criterion puts the heard moment there. The buttons play this attack against a two-millisecond one, started at the same instant.

A note is heard after it starts

Every rhythm essay until now has treated a note's onset as the moment it happens. It is not: the instant a listener aligns a note with a beat is later than its physical start by an amount the note's own attack decides, and for a sung or bowed note that amount is about thirty milliseconds — the size of the whole quantity six essays on microtiming set out to measure.

rhythm · Perceptual-centre

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Attack transientFusionOnsetRoughnessCanonCommon fateCounterpointEnsemble asynchronyEnvelopeHarmonic rhythmHarmonicityHearing out

All concepts