Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Hearing out — where it appears

Attending to one partial of a complex tone as a separate sound. It is possible only below the point where consecutive partials fall inside one auditory filter, which is around the eighth partial for a fundamental in the middle of the range.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Partial 3, mistuned by 3%. A 10-partial tone on 220 Hz with one partial treated differently from the rest. Mistuning it moves it off the harmonic grid by 3.0 per cent, which is 19.8 Hz — slow enough to be heard as a beat rather than as a separate pitch, and enough for the partial to be heard out of the note as a whistle of its own. An onset difference does the same to a partial that is exactly in tune.

What makes two partials one note

A note is a stack of ten or twenty simultaneous tones and is heard as one thing. The obvious explanation is that they are whole-number multiples of a fundamental — and the obvious explanation is not sufficient. Mistune one partial by three per cent and it leaves the note; give a perfectly harmonic partial a thirty-millisecond head start and it leaves too. Shared behaviour beats arithmetic.

timbre · Auditory scene The series has three tops. Where the harmonic series stops, asked three ways, at four fundamentals. Consecutive partials stop being separately resolvable around partial 8 — that one depends on the fundamental, since a critical band is a fixed width in hertz and the spacing is not. They stop being a semitone apart at partial 17 at every fundamental, because the ratio (n+1)/n does not know what n is measured in. And they stop being distinguishable in pitch at all between partials 34 and 140. Every claim about how far up the series something happens is a claim about which of these three was meant.

The series has three tops

How far up the harmonic series can an ear go? The question has three answers and they are an order of magnitude apart. Consecutive partials stop being separately resolvable somewhere around the eighth, and where exactly depends on the fundamental. They stop being a semitone apart at the seventeenth, at every fundamental, because the ratio does not know what it is measured in. And they stop being distinguishable in pitch at all between the thirty-fourth and the hundred and fortieth. Every claim about where the series runs out is a claim about which of the three was meant.

intervals · Harmonic series Of 8 beats at A3, 3 can be attended to. Every member of the beat family a 2:1 mistuned by 6.0 cents makes on a real string at A3, placed by how separable its coincidence is from the partials beside it — in auditory filter widths, across — and by how fast it beats, up. The shaded region is the set a listener can receive: wider than one filter, and between 0.4 and 15 fluctuations a second. 4 of 8 members fall inside it, and once rates within a factor of 2 are counted as one modulation channel there are 3. The members that fail do so for two different reasons: the low ones sit under the roughness ceiling but their coincidences are buried in a filter that holds three partials, and the high ones are resolved and far too fast.

Three beats at most, and only in the middle of the keyboard

A mistuned octave on a real piano makes eight beats at once, and a listener attending to one of them is doing something that has a threshold. Two thresholds, in fact — a rate and a place — and once both are applied the eight become four at A3, one at A1 and one at A5. Every interval a tuner sets goes to zero at both ends of the compass and peaks at eight countable beats in the octave the bearing is laid in.

intervals · Beating

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Critical bandwidthPartialResolvabilityBeatingCommon fateDifference limenDominance regionFusionHarmonic seriesHarmonicityInharmonicityJust-noticeable difference

All concepts