Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Common fate — where it appears

The grouping principle by which components that change together are heard as one object: partials that start, stop or move in step belong to one source. It is the fusion cue harmonicity cannot express, because a list of frequency ratios has no time in it.

Named by 5 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Partial 3, mistuned by 3%. A 10-partial tone on 220 Hz with one partial treated differently from the rest. Mistuning it moves it off the harmonic grid by 3.0 per cent, which is 19.8 Hz — slow enough to be heard as a beat rather than as a separate pitch, and enough for the partial to be heard out of the note as a whistle of its own. An onset difference does the same to a partial that is exactly in tune.

What makes two partials one note

A note is a stack of ten or twenty simultaneous tones and is heard as one thing. The obvious explanation is that they are whole-number multiples of a fundamental — and the obvious explanation is not sufficient. Mistune one partial by three per cent and it leaves the note; give a perfectly harmonic partial a thirty-millisecond head start and it leaves too. Shared behaviour beats arithmetic.

timbre · Auditory scene Two fusion cues, and they do not agree about a single spectrum. Each spectrum twice. Hollow is the harmonicity census — the fraction of partials near enough a whole multiple of one fundamental to fuse, which is harmonicity. Filled is the same fraction under common fate: how many partials decay at a rate within a factor of 2 of the strongest partial's. Ranked by harmonicity the order is an ideal string, a piano string, a bell, a kettledrum, a bar; ranked by common fate it is a kettledrum, a bar, an ideal string, a piano string, a bell. The two orderings are nearly reversed. An ideal string is perfect on the first cue and 20 per cent on the second, and a kettledrum — the worst spectrum in this collection for fitting a series — is the only one whose partials all die together.

The partials that do not die together

The fusion census is a still photograph: it asks whether a set of partials fits one harmonic series and has no term for time. Put time in and the ranking reverses. An ideal string is perfect on harmonicity and holds a fifth of its partials together by decay; a kettledrum — the worst spectrum in this collection for fitting a series — is the only one whose modes all die at one rate.

perception · Auditory scene What a competition decides when the two cues do not agree. Each spectrum with its two cue readings and the grouping the competition chooses. Harmonicity asks whether a partial is near enough a whole multiple to belong; common fate asks whether it decays at the same rate as the rest. Where they disagree there is no rule in this collection, so the published apparatus is used instead: every way of splitting the partials into one stream or two is scored for the partials each cue says it has wrongly grouped and wrongly separated, and the cheapest wins. an ideal string — harmonicity 100 per cent, common fate 20, and the competition says one stream; a piano string — harmonicity 90 per cent, common fate 20, and the competition says a cut after partial 2; a bell — harmonicity 88 per cent, common fate 13, and the competition says a cut after partial 1; a bar — harmonicity 33 per cent, common fate 67, and the competition says a cut after partial 4; a kettledrum — harmonicity 60 per cent, common fate 100, and the competition says one stream. The exchange rate between the two cues is the number nobody here can supply, so what is reported beside each is how many decades of it leave the answer unchanged.

The exchange rate nobody has

There are now two cues that disagree about how a spectrum divides, and every figure so far reports them separately because there is no principled way here to weigh one against the other. The published apparatus is a competition between grouping hypotheses with a cost per cue — and the useful thing it produces is not the winner but how much of the exchange rate the winner survives.

perception · Auditory scene The cue that settles it. Every spectrum to hand, arbitrated by the earlier competition and then again with the onset cue added at equal weight. 3 of the 5 change their verdict, and all 3 change the same way — from splitting into two streams to staying as one: a piano string, a bell, a bar. Nothing changes the other way, because the onset cue on a struck source votes for fusion on every partial and can only ever push toward one stream. The bell is the case worth naming: its partials are wildly inharmonic and it is heard as one sound, which is a fact the harmonicity cue alone cannot produce.

The cue that settles it

Arbitrating between two grouping cues meant sweeping an exchange rate nobody could supply. The cue it had no term for at all is the one every account calls strongest, and its strength is computable: a struck string's partials start together to within a tenth of a millisecond against a threshold of twenty. Put that into the competition and three of five verdicts change, all the same way — and a bell becomes one sound.

perception · Auditory scene A clarinet's partials, each on its own resonance. The 8 partials of the clarinet's chalumeau D that ride an impedance peak, each building toward its steady amplitude as 1 − exp(−t/τ) with τ = Q/πf from that peak's own Q. The time constants run from 11.9 milliseconds to 64.5, so the partials do not arrive at different times — they all begin the instant the reed does — and what differs is how fast each approaches its final level. The horizontal bars are how far apart the first and last are at three criteria: 5.5 ms at 10 per cent, 36.4 ms at 50 per cent, 121.0 ms at 90 per cent. A twenty-millisecond asynchrony is the threshold for hearing a partial out of a note, and this note crosses it at 32 per cent of steady amplitude — so whether a blown note's onset cue is unanimous or divided is decided entirely by how far along a partial has to be before it counts as having started.

A blown note does not start late, it starts slowly

Computing the onset cue removed a free parameter and turned out to be unanimous, and it predicted that a wind instrument would put it back, because a blown note's partials arrive over tens of milliseconds. They do — 121 on a clarinet — and it is not an asynchrony: every partial begins the instant the reed does and they differ in rate, not in time. Read at a tenth of the steady amplitude the spread is 5.5 milliseconds against a threshold of twenty, so the cue is still unanimous, and the missing number is no longer the exchange rate but the criterion.

perception · Auditory scene

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

FusionAuditory scene analysisPartialHarmonicityInharmonicityOnsetStreamingTimbreAir columnAttack transientDecayEnvelope

All concepts