Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Overblowing — where it appears

Driving a wind instrument harder, or venting it, so that it sounds a higher mode of the same tube instead of its fundamental. Which mode it reaches depends on the bore: a cylinder closed at one end goes up a twelfth and a cone an octave.

Named by 8 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

What a 60 cm tube supports, by how its ends are closed. The first 6 modes of an open cylinder and a stopped cylinder, all of the same acoustic length. An open tube supports every whole multiple of the fundamental and reaches the second mode an octave up. A cylinder stopped at one end supports only the odd multiples and reaches its second mode 1902 cents up, which is a twelfth. Its fundamental is also an octave below the others, because it fits a quarter of a wavelength where they fit a half.

A tube that skips every other partial

Stop one end of a cylinder and half its modes vanish. That single fact about where the pressure has to be decides that a clarinet sounds hollow, that it plays an octave below its length suggests, and that it must cover nineteen semitones with fingers before it can overblow — while every other woodwind covers twelve.

instruments · Air column What a 60 cm tube supports, by how its ends are closed. The first 6 modes of a stopped cylinder and a cone, all of the same acoustic length. A cone supports every whole multiple of the fundamental and reaches the second mode an octave up. A cylinder stopped at one end supports only the odd multiples and reaches its second mode 1902 cents up, which is a twelfth. Its fundamental is also an octave below the others, because it fits a quarter of a wavelength where they fit a half.

A cone is not a cylinder

A saxophone has a reed at a closed end, exactly as a clarinet does, and it overblows at the octave rather than the twelfth. If the previous essay's argument were about reeds that would refute it. It is about geometry, and a cone closed at its apex has the complete harmonic series for a reason that takes one line of algebra and is genuinely surprising.

instruments · Air column One register vent, 12 fingerings. Where the second mode's pressure node sits for each fingering of a stopped tube, against a single register hole drilled 12 cm from the mouthpiece. The node is a third of the way along the sounding length, so it moves every time a hole is opened, and the vent's error runs from -38 to -1 cents across the range. A perfect register system would need one hole per fingering. The number of holes actually fitted is one, and the leftover is a design decision rather than a fault.

One hole doing a dozen jobs

A register key works by forcing a pressure node where the second mode already has one, which kills the fundamental and leaves the mode above. The node sits a fixed fraction along the sounding length — and the sounding length changes with every fingering, while the hole stays where it was drilled. The leftover error is computable, and it is why the throat notes are the ones players complain about.

instruments · Tone holes Two mechanisms, the notes both of them make, and the seam. The frequency range of each laryngeal mechanism for an adult male voice, on a logarithmic axis, with the band both can produce shaded. M1 — chest runs 82–349 Hz and M2 — falsetto runs 220–698 Hz, so 799 cents of the range — 8.0 semitones — can be sung either way. The two dots inside that band are the measured signature that this is a bifurcation rather than a threshold: the change upward happens at 330 Hz and the change downward at 294 Hz, 200 cents lower. A threshold is crossed at the same place in both directions and this is not.

Two mechanisms, and the seam between them

Every singer has a place in the range where the voice changes character, and eight semitones of it can be produced either way. The measurement that settles what kind of a place it is takes ten seconds: the change upward happens two hundred cents higher than the change downward, and a threshold cannot do that.

instruments · The voice A reed that shuts at 5000 pascals, and the air it lets through. Volume flow through the reed channel against the pressure across it, in the quasi-static model: Bernoulli flow through an opening that closes linearly with pressure. The flow peaks at 1667 pascals — exactly a third of the closing pressure, for any reed, because that is where the two effects balance — and it is 0.18 litres a second there. Everything to the right of that peak is the argument: the flow falls as the player blows harder, from 0.18 to 0.05 litres a second by 4500 pascals, and a resistance that behaves that way supplies energy instead of taking it. There is no reed inertia in this model, so it cannot squeak.

The reed is a valve, not a vibrator

Three essays here have said that a clarinet's reed does not choose the note, and none of them said what it does instead. It chops a steady stream of air, and past a third of the pressure that closes it the flow falls as the player blows harder — a resistance with the wrong sign, which is the only thing in the instrument capable of putting energy into an oscillation that is otherwise losing it.

instruments · Air column One key, nineteen notes, one right answer. A register hole disturbs a mode in proportion to the square of that mode's pressure at the hole, so the place that spoils the fundamental and leaves the third harmonic alone is the third harmonic's own pressure node — a third of the way down whatever length is sounding. The length changes with every fingering and the key does not move, so the two curves cross at one note. At A3 the key sits almost exactly on the node and the twelfth speaks cleanly; at A♭4 it is at 62 per cent of the tube and disturbs the third harmonic by 96 per cent of what an antinode would, which is the throat of the instrument and is exactly where players say the notes are worst.

The hole that spoils a note

A tone hole shortens the tube. A register hole does the opposite job: it is small enough to shorten nothing and is placed where it will wreck the fundamental's resonance and leave the third harmonic's alone, so the note jumps a twelfth instead of retuning. The place that does both is a pressure node of the harmonic being kept — a third of the way along whatever length is sounding — and the length changes with every fingering while the key does not. One key is at the right place for exactly one note, and the note it is worst for is in the throat of the instrument, which is where players say the instrument is worst.

instruments · Tone holes Blowing harder is playing sharper. How far the played note is pulled from the bore's own resonance, against blowing pressure, for an air jet crossing a 4 mm embouchure. The jet's preferred frequency goes as the square root of the pressure, so it rises by a factor of 3.16 across the tenfold pressure range drawn, and the bore holds it to 272 cents of that — from -174 at the quietest to +98 at the loudest, about the player's own nominal. The rows below give the same pull for a drive one semitone sharp of the bore, for four valves: a clarinet reed is damped by the lip and pulls 4.9 cents, brass lips are not and pull 23.6.

Blowing harder is playing sharper

Every frequency computed so far for an air column is a resonance of the tube, and no wind instrument plays at its bore's resonance. It plays between the bore and whatever is driving it, weighted by how sharply each is tuned — and a flute's driver is an air jet whose own preferred frequency goes as the square root of the blowing pressure. Across a tenfold pressure range the jet's preference rises by a factor of 3.16 and the bore holds it to 112 cents of that. A wind player's dynamics and their intonation are one control, and the size of the coupling between them is the valve's Q.

tuning · Air column One vent on a cone, over the notes it has to serve. A cone's modes are a full harmonic series, so the mode a register vent has to keep is the octave rather than the twelfth, and its pressure node sits at half the sounding length measured from the virtual apex. The apex is a fixed point of the instrument and the bell end is not, so every fingering moves the ideal position and there is one hole. The upper line is how much the vent spoils the fundamental, which is what it is for; the lower is how much it damages the octave, which is the cost. Their ratio runs from 451.2 at F♯4 down to 1.9 at B♭3 — a factor of 235 across a single register. The vent is placed at 37 per cent of the longest sounding length, which is where the worst fingering is least badly served.

The vent a cone cannot place

A clarinet's register key has to spoil a fundamental and leave a twelfth. A saxophone's has to spoil a fundamental and leave an octave, whose pressure node sits at half the sounding length from the virtual apex — and the apex is a fixed point while the bell end is not. Over one register the ideal position moves by a factor of two, and one hole is right for one note.

instruments · Tone holes

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

BoreRegisterBoundary conditionStanding waveIntonationResonanceTone holeHarmonic seriesNegative resistanceNodeNonlinearityReed

All concepts