Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Detuning — where it appears

A deliberate difference in pitch between two sources meant to sound as one, measured in cents or in beats per second. Below a few cents it buys sustain and above a dozen it buys width, and the two policies cannot both be held across a range because cents and hertz scale differently.

Named by 7 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

What a chorus costs on one bridge. The sixty-decibel time of the longest-lived mode of two coupled strings at 262 hertz, against how far apart they are tuned. Below the bifurcation at 4.5 cents the pair splits its decays and one mode rings on; above it the pair splits its frequencies instead, both modes carry the bridge's loss, and the sustain sits at 2.8 seconds however much further the tuning is opened. The flat line is what the same two strings would do if they did not share a bridge. A chorused sound and a long one cannot be had from one bridge, and the first four and a half cents cost all of it.

The pair tuned apart on purpose

A piano's unison buys its sustain with a detuning of two and a half cents and loses it past four and a half. Read from the other side that is a design constraint on every instrument that wants the beating instead: past the bifurcation the sustain is gone and no further detuning costs anything more, which is why every chorused voice in the world — the celeste rank, the musette reeds, the paired gamelan — is built out of sources that do not share a bridge.

tuning · Beating One pair, 12 beat rates. Two notes at 220 hertz, 15 cents apart, drawn as the beat rate between each pair of partials. The fundamentals beat at 1.91 hertz and the k-th partials at k times that, so the series of rates is a straight line and it crosses 15 hertz at the 8th partial. Below the line the fluctuation is counted; above it the same physical fluctuation is heard as roughness. 1 per cent of this spectrum's energy is on the roughness side. The bars are drawn at each partial's own amplitude, so a spectrum with little energy high up crosses the line where nothing is listening.

Every partial beats at its own rate

Five earlier essays have drawn one beat rate per figure, and every one of them is the rate between two fundamentals. Two real notes beat between all of their partials at once, the k-th pair beats k times as fast, and somewhere up the spectrum the rate passes the point at which a beat stops being a beat — so a chorused note is a beat at the bottom of itself and a roughness at the top, simultaneously, with a crossover partial that is arithmetic.

tuning · Beating A wrong bar costs the same whichever instrument it is on. What moving one degree of a measured slendro by 10 cents, flat or sharp, adds to the roughness per second of a two-instrument texture — a ringing part at 0.15 s a note over a damped one four times slower — on the ringing instrument and on the damped one. The ensemble in tune scores 7.47. Degree 1 (0¢): ringing 0.142 flat and 0.202 sharp, damped 0.163 and 0.185, of which beating 0.178; Degree 2 (231¢): ringing 0.119 flat and 0.068 sharp, damped 0.096 and 0.090, of which beating 0.093; Degree 3 (474¢): ringing 0.106 flat and 0.021 sharp, damped 0.069 and 0.057, of which beating 0.063; Degree 5 (717¢): ringing 0.079 flat and 0.072 sharp, damped 0.075 and 0.078, of which beating 0.077; Degree 6 (955¢): ringing 0.023 flat and 0.018 sharp, damped 0.019 and 0.022, of which beating 0.020. Over all ten errors the ringing instrument's cost 0.85 and the damped one's 0.85, and the wrong bar beating against the other instrument's right one comes to 0.86 on either — as much as the whole, because the intervals the error changes add as often as they save. One error costs about 1.1% of the texture's roughness.

A wrong bar beats the same on either instrument

The ringing instrument carries a gamelan scale's standing, so a tuning error on it was predicted to cost more than the same error on the damped instrument. Put in the beating the model lacked, and the prediction fails: moved ten cents, a degree costs the same 0.85 summed over the scale on either instrument, because almost all of the cost is the wrong bar beating against the right one on the other instrument, and a beat belongs to both of the bars that make it. Moving a whole instrument costs exactly what its five degrees cost separately, and it takes nothing from the scale's standing.

scales · Beyond twelve The bar a tuner can least afford to leave wrong is the one the skeleton lands on. What a 10-cent error on each degree of a measured slendro adds to the roughness per second of a two-instrument texture over 128 bars, averaged over both instruments and both directions, with the elaborating part meeting the skeleton on the last stroke of every four-stroke unit. Top row: the skeleton's degrees drawn at random. Each row below: the skeleton ending every unit on one degree. Random: 1 0.219, 2 0.054, 3 0.083, 5 0.095, 6 0.104. Ending on 1: 1 0.348, 2 0.028, 3 0.049, 5 0.062, 6 0.068. Ending on 2: 1 0.171, 2 0.228, 3 0.049, 5 0.064, 6 0.067. Ending on 3: 1 0.170, 2 0.028, 3 0.247, 5 0.064, 6 0.068. Ending on 5: 1 0.170, 2 0.028, 3 0.049, 5 0.285, 6 0.069. Ending on 6: 1 0.171, 2 0.027, 3 0.049, 5 0.064, 6 0.305. The tonic's error moves its octave too, so it is two bars. In every row the degree the units end on costs the most, three and a half to five times what the dearest other single bar costs.

The bar a gamelan can least afford wrong is the one its skeleton lands on

A wrong bar in a gamelan costs what its beating against the other instrument costs, and that depends on how often the music doubles the degree. The obvious place for doubling is where an elaborating part meets the skeleton at the end of each four-stroke unit, so the prediction was that the meeting rule would rank the degrees. It barely does: a part left to ring doubles a degree whenever it sounds it while the other instrument's bar still sounds, and the meetings add three per cent. What ranks the degrees is where the skeleton lands. A skeleton that ends its units on one degree makes that bar three and a half to five times as costly to leave wrong as any other single bar.

scales · Beyond twelve An elaboration that arrives early makes all three goal tones the dearest bars. What a 10-cent error on each degree costs, for a skeleton whose four-stroke units end on 6, 2 or 3, with the elaborating part meeting the goal on the unit's last stroke and arriving on it 0, 3 or 7 of its own strokes earlier. 0 early: 1 0.171, 2 0.097, 3 0.082, 5 0.064, 6 0.161. 3 early: 1 0.139, 2 0.115, 3 0.106, 5 0.056, 6 0.221. 7 early: 1 0.100, 2 0.159, 3 0.136, 5 0.043, 6 0.295. Meeting on the stroke, the goal on 3 costs no more than degree 3 does with the skeleton at random; arriving seven strokes early, the cheapest goal costs 3.2 times the dearest single bar that is not a goal.

An elaboration that arrives early makes every goal tone the bar to tune first

A gamelan's bars are costliest to leave out of tune where the skeleton lands, but a mode with three goal tones spread the cost so thinly that a low goal could end up cheaper than a high bar that is never a goal. The rule tested there put the elaborating part on the goal only at the goal stroke. Elaborations in the style reach their goal early and stay on it. Let them arrive seven strokes early and every goal tone costs more than three times the dearest bar that is not a goal; the goal's own cost rises by about half for every few strokes of anticipation, and a whole instrument out of tune becomes dearer too.

scales · Beyond twelve A gamelan's goal-tone beating is a clock hand only if each goal beats at its own rate. Bits of position unknown over the first cycle of a sixteen-step cycle of gong, kempul and kenong, against the cycle's duration, when the elaborating parts arrive early on each goal tone — kenong and gong on degrees 2 3 2 6 — and a pair of instruments tuned apart beats on it for a step before the stroke: with the pairs tuned together (no swell), tuned apart at one beat rate for every degree, tuned apart by 25 cents so that each degree beats at its own rate (told apart when the rates differ by 15 per cent), and with every swell told apart. tuned together: no swell: 40 s 0.112, 60 s 0.203, 80 s 0.329, 120 s 0.417, 160 s 0.646, 240 s 0.870. tuned apart at one beat rate: 40 s 0.104, 60 s 0.192, 80 s 0.301, 120 s 0.376, 160 s 0.404, 240 s 0.576. tuned apart by 25 cents: 40 s 0.076, 60 s 0.114, 80 s 0.125, 120 s 0.137, 160 s 0.146, 240 s 0.285. every swell told apart: 40 s 0.000, 60 s 0.000, 80 s 0.000, 120 s 0.000, 160 s 0.003, 240 s 0.132.

A gamelan's beating names its goal only if each goal beats at its own rate

When a gamelan's elaborating parts reach a goal tone early, a pair of instruments tuned slightly apart beats on that degree for the strokes before the goal — a swell of shimmer just before each structural stroke, which is exactly where a recognisable event does a slow cycle's clock most good. Whether it does that good depends on whether one goal's swell can be told from another's. Tune every pair to the same beat rate, the practice that keeps a gamelan's shimmer even, and every swell is the same event: it buys a third of what it could. Tune every pair the same number of cents apart and each degree beats at its own rate, fifteen per cent faster than the degree below, and the swells start naming which goal is coming.

scales · Beyond twelve Naming the goals costs no roughness: it saves a little. Pairs tuned apart so that each slendro degree's pair beats at a rate proportional to its pitch raised to a power — nought for one rate on every degree, one for a constant interval, more than one for a rate rising faster than the pitch — with the average rate held at 5.01 beats a second. Line: the roughness the detuned pairs add to the goal-tone passage, as a share of what one rate adds — 0 100.0%, 0.5 99.7%, 0.75 99.4%, 1 99.0%, 1.25 98.5%, 1.5 98.1%, 2 97.3%, 2.5 96.4%, 3 95.6%. Steps: the bits of position the swells leave unknown at 160 seconds a cycle, rates told apart at 15 per cent — 0 0.404 (AAAA), 0.5 0.404 (AAAA), 0.75 0.226 (AAAB), 1 0.146 (ABAC), 1.25 0.146 (ABAC), 1.5 0.146 (ABAC), 2 0.146 (ABAC), 2.5 0.146 (ABAC), 3 0.146 (ABAC). Every steeper rise costs less roughness, and from a constant interval upward the swells name three different goals.

A gamelan tuner can name the goals for nothing

A pair tuned so that each goal beats at its own rate lets the swells before a gamelan's structural strokes say which goal is coming, and the question left was what that costs in roughness. Held at the same average shimmer, nothing: a constant interval adds one per cent less roughness than an even beat rate, and a rate rising as the square of the pitch adds three per cent less while naming the goals for a far coarser ear. The even shimmer puts its widest pairs on the low degrees, where a cent of detuning costs most.

scales · Beyond twelve

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

BeatingRoughnessSlendroIntonationScale degreeChorus effectCycleWeber fractionCoupled oscillatorCritical bandwidthGamelanInformation

All concepts