Concept

Detection — where it appears

The smallest fluctuation a listener notices at all, as against the smallest difference between two of them that can be told apart. For a beat it is published as a fraction of the carrier that rises steeply with rate, and running a computed modulation index against it turns a table of decibels into a window in cents.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

How far out of tune an interval has to be before its beat is usable. An earlier essay produced a modulation index for every interval on a stated timbre; whether a fluctuation of that index at that rate can be detected is a published function of both. Running one against the other turns a table of decibels into a window in cents. The bar is the mistuning over which the beat is both deep enough to notice and at a rate a tuner can use — not so slow that a beat takes half a minute to complete, not so fast that it has stopped being a beat. the major third gives the widest window, 1.3 to 60.0 cents, and the minor sixth the narrowest, 0.8 to 38.9. The ordering is the opposite of the dip's: the octave has the shallowest dip on a string spectrum and the widest usable window, because its coincidence sits at a low partial and a given mistuning therefore produces a slower beat. Depth and rate pull opposite ways, and it is the rate that decides.

The beat a tuner can actually use

There is a modulation index for every interval on every timbre, and the published threshold for detecting a fluctuation is a function of exactly that and its rate. Running one against the other turns a table of decibels into a window in cents — and reverses the ordering, because the interval with the shallowest dip has the widest window.

intervals · Beating

Every beat in a family is the same depth, and none is near the threshold. The 8 members of the beat family a octave mistuned by 6.0 cents makes at A3 on a real string, each placed at the rate it beats and at the modulation index a listener's filter delivers there. The rising curve is the published detection threshold for amplitude modulation, which is flat at 0.03 below about fifty fluctuations a second and rises above it. The flat dashed line at 0.667 is the depth the pair has in isolation, and it is the same for every member: on a spectrum falling as one over n, the k-th member pairs partials 2k and 1k, whose ratio is 2.00 whatever k is. What the filled points show is the smaller effect that does depend on the member — the partials on either side of the coincidence leak into the same filter, add level without adding fluctuation, and dilute the index from 0.662 to 0.405. Inside the countable rate window the narrowest margin over the threshold is a factor of 16.7, on member 4. The depth criterion removes nothing.

Every member of a beat family is the same depth

A mistuned octave's beats have been counted on their rate and their place, with the depth recorded as the thing left out and a prediction that the shallow upper members would take the count from four to two. The depth turns out not to fall at all: on any power-law spectrum every member of a family has exactly the modulation index its interval's own ratio gives, at every register, on every wire. The count does fall to two, and the thing that takes it there is the criterion that essay was already using.

intervals · Beating

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Beating Modulation Partial Tuning by ear Amplitude Critical bandwidth Piano Resolvability Spectrum Temperament Timbre Weber fraction

All concepts