Every essay — page 7
Pitch and tuning Intervals and chords Scales and modes Harmony and voice leading Rhythm and metre Timbre and acoustics Perception and the listener Instruments and their design Form and structure Series Objects Sounds Search
Scales and modes
Which seven of the twelve, and what changes when the same seven start somewhere else.
Seven of the twelve, chosen unevenly
A major scale is a selection of seven positions out of twelve, and the selection is lopsided on purpose. The two semitones sit where they do because an even choice would destroy the thing that makes a scale usable.
The same seven, started later
A mode is not a new scale. It is the same seven notes with a different one treated as home, and the entire change in character comes from reassigning which degree the semitones fall next to.
Keys are neighbours, and the map is computed
Two keys a fifth apart share six of their seven notes. That single fact generates the circle of fifths, the key signatures, the shape of nearly every modulation, and the sense that some keys are far away.
Five notes, and no semitones
The five black keys sound acceptable in any combination, in any order, over almost any bass note. That is not mysticism and not luck — five is the longest a chain of fifths can run before it produces a semitone, and the number is derived rather than chosen.
What a raised seventh is for
The harmonic minor is usually taught as a scale with an odd gap in it. It is better understood as a repair to a single chord — raising the seventh degree turns the dominant triad from minor to major, and everything else about the scale is the bill for that.
A scale is not a set of pitches
Two ragas can have identical pitch sets and be different ragas. Two national theories of one maqam put its third degree thirty-five cents apart. Both facts are fatal to the idea that a mode is a collection of notes, and both are ordinary in the traditions concerned.
Two sizes of every step, which is why the names work
A third is three semitones or four, and every musician learns to call both of them thirds without being told why that is allowed. It is allowed because of a property the diatonic scale has and 448 of the other 461 seven-note selections from the twelve do not.
A scale without an octave, and the spectrum that asks for it
Every scale so far repeats at the 2:1. That looks like a law and it is a consequence — the octave fuses because every partial of the upper note lands on one of the lower. Take a spectrum with no even partials and the 2:1 stops doing that, while the 3:1 starts.
Where the chain was never closed
Eleven earlier essays treat the comma as a fact about music. It is a fact about three requirements — that the scale is built from fifths, that the octave stays pure, and that the chain closes so any degree can be a tonic — and most of the world's tuning traditions decline at least one of them. What they pay instead is computable, and it is paid somewhere else entirely.
Every interval a different number of times
Count the intervals inside a major scale and the six answers are 2, 5, 4, 3, 6 and 1 — six different numbers, no two alike. That is not decoration. It means the number of notes a key shares with a transposition of itself identifies the distance uniquely, so a listener who can only count common tones can still tell exactly how far a modulation went.
The same algorithm made a Cuban rhythm
Ask Bjorklund's algorithm for seven onsets in twelve steps and it returns 101101011010, which read as pitch classes is the natural minor scale. That function has been producing the tresillo and the cinquillo here from the beginning, and nobody has said that the scale field's central object comes out of it unchanged.
Why seven
Four properties, each shared with some other set. Run all four over every subset of the twelve, at every size from two notes to eleven — three hundred and forty-nine shapes in all — and exactly one has all four at once. It is the diatonic set, and it is the only survivor in the whole twelve-note universe.
The only sizes a fifth will make
Stack pure fifths and fold them into an octave, and at almost every number of notes the result has three or more different step sizes. At 2, 3, 5, 7, 12, 17 and 29 it has exactly two — and at no other size below thirty. The pentatonic and the diatonic set are not two discoveries. They are neighbours in one series, and it is the comma's series.
Nothing in the census knows which note is home
All four properties six earlier essays are about are invariant under rotation and transposition — one property tuple over all eighty-four rotations and transpositions of the diatonic set. So the census that separates 349 shapes cannot separate a major scale from its own Aeolian mode, and everything that makes one note a tonic is outside it.
Seven rotations that are not seven modes
Rotate harmonic minor and the result is not a family the way the diatonic modes are a family. Four of its six generic intervals come in three specific sizes rather than two, so a fourth might be four, five or six semitones; three of its seven rotations have no fifth above their own tonic; and four have a tonic inside a tritone. The word mode has been doing two different jobs.
Parallel and relative are two different maps
Bring the seven modes to one tonic and order them by brightness, and each step lowers exactly one note by a semitone — and the notes it lowers, in order, are F♯, B, E, A, D, G, the chain of fifths read backwards. Do the same to harmonic minor's rotations and each step moves two, three or four notes at once. The famous chain belongs to the generator, not to rotation.
The circle is a circle, and the map is not
Among the twelve major keys, notes in common is a strict function of distance round the circle of fifths — one value for each step count, no exceptions — so there is nothing else to measure and the map really is one-dimensional. A second axis appears only when the minor keys are added, and it is a different kind of move: the relative shares all seven notes and the parallel is one semitone away.
A scale built downward from a fourth
A tetrachord is a bounded span with two free notes inside it, which is a different generator from a chain of fifths and a different object from a subset of an equal division. At the maqam tradition's own quarter-tone resolution the construction admits thirty-six fillings of the fourth and 1,296 octaves built from them; the census here can see six of the first and 2.8 per cent of the second, and one of the octaves it cannot see is an ordinary mode of a living tradition.
A melody is a walk, not a set
Nine essays here are about which seven of the twelve a scale takes, and every one of them describes a set. A tune is not a set; it is a path across one, and the path is nearly all small steps. That is not a matter of taste. Above about eight notes a second the ear stops being able to hold a large interval and a small one in the same line, and at sixteen the choice disappears altogether — so a fast passage is scalar because a fast passage that leaps is two pieces of music.
A degree is where it goes next
The first essay on scales beyond twelve said a mode is not a set and listed four things a set cannot record. This one makes the sharpest of them arithmetic. Specify a mode as an ascent and a descent — which is how a living tradition specifies one — and it becomes a directed graph on its degrees; sixty-three such graphs collapse onto a single pentatonic set, sixty-two of them with an ascent that is not the descent reversed, and every standard measure of a scale returns the same value for all of them.
The stave is not a ruler
A hundred and eighty essays here draw pitch against an axis somebody computed. The one axis every reader already owns is the five lines, and it is not a pitch axis at all: it counts letters. Seven positions carry twelve pitches, so the same vertical distance is two intervals before an accidental is allowed and six after — and the accidental is not an extra symbol on a complete scale but the repair for a scale with five values missing.
The one note that decides the mode
A key signature names the seven and not the rotation, so the mode has to be heard. Enumerate every set of degrees that lies inside at least one of the seven modes — 510 of them — and count how many modes each leaves standing. Fifteen minimal sets decide, every one has two members, and every one is the mode's own tritone. The only degree all seven share is the tonic; no degree belongs to a single mode; and averaged over the orders the degrees could arrive in, 5.67 of the seven have to have been heard first.
The set with fewer modes than notes
Eight earlier essays rotate one collection, and the seven modes were never a result — they are arithmetic. A set has as many modes as it has notes divided by the order of its own transposition symmetry, so the whole-tone scale has six notes and one mode, the octatonic has eight and two, and the question asked just before — how much has to be heard before the mode is settled — is not merely hard for those collections but undefined. Seventy-five of the twelve-note universe's 4,095 subsets are built this way and they reduce to sixteen step patterns. Five, seven and eleven notes cannot be among them, which is why every seven-note scale has seven modes before anybody plays one.
The clef is an integer
The first essay on notation found that the staff's vertical axis counts letters rather than pitch, and named the clef as a question it was leaving open. Paid, it is arithmetic: a staff holds eleven letters, no voice or instrument is that narrow, and the eight clefs of European practice step through the axis in thirds — a spacing that buys everything a set of fifteen would buy on a wide range, for eight.