Every essay — page 6
Pitch and tuning Intervals and chords Scales and modes Harmony and voice leading Rhythm and metre Timbre and acoustics Perception and the listener Instruments and their design Form and structure Series Objects Sounds Search
Intervals and chords
Two notes at once, why some of them beat, and the geometry of the ones that do not.
A minor triad can be spaced to last
Two spacings of each triad, drawn side by side, say that opening lengthens a major chord and halves a minor one. Drawn over every arrangement of the three pitch classes within two octaves of a fixed bass, the asymmetry disappears: a minor triad reaches 1.26 seconds over C3 and so does a major one, with two spacings of each tied at the top. The short-lived chords were never the minor ones. They were the ones with a minor tenth on the outside, and a minor triad has three spacings that avoid it.
Three harmonics of the bass arrive before the bass
Every product priced until now was between two pure tones, and nothing that plays thirds is pure. Give each note a spectrum and the ear receives every pair of partials — and for a just interval p:q every one of their products is an exact multiple of the same absent fundamental. That crowd lands where the threshold of hearing is tens of decibels cheaper, so it names the bass at 71 decibels where the component at the bass's own frequency needs 74, and at 75 against 85 an octave lower. Tempered, the crowd still forms and names a note seventy cents flat.
The ghost bass drops a twelfth at a forte
Both crowds arrive at once and every member of both is a multiple of the same absent fundamental, so a listener is never given a choice between them — only a different subset of one harmonic series at every dynamic. Softly, the subset is an exact gapless series on three times the fundamental. Loudly, the difference tones fill in the low harmonics and no template on the higher note survives them. Between 62 and 72 decibels, depending on the interval, the note the crowd names falls by an octave or a twelfth, and the two qualities of third cross at different levels.
The played notes already name the ghost bass
The products of a just third's partials, fitted on their own, name a note a twelfth above the bass when the interval is soft and drop to the bass when it is loud. Put the two played notes back beside them and the drop disappears: the notes and their products name the bass at every dynamic, because the notes' own partials are harmonics of it already. What the dynamic changes is not which note is implied but how complete its harmonic series is — nine holes from the notes alone, four when soft, none when loud.
A firm touch buys beats until the aftersound sinks with it
A piano string decays twice, and a mistuned octave's countable beats were found to rise with how hard the note is struck — on the assumption that the aftersound always starts twenty decibels below the strike. It need not. The moment the count shuts is set by the level the aftersound starts at and nothing else, so a harder strike buys beats only if its aftersound does not sink with it. If the drop deepens by more than 0.85 decibels for each decibel of strike, the firm touch costs beats instead.
A tempered third cannot be one sound with its own ghost
The essay before this one fitted one harmonic template to a just third's played partials and the products of those partials together, and it worked at every dynamic. Tempered, it does not work at all — and not by naming a different note. There is no template. The lower note's partials sit exactly on their harmonics, the upper note's are every one fourteen cents out, and the products are twenty-three cents out the other way, a span of thirty-seven cents across a tolerance of thirty. The window is nine cents wide when the third is soft and two when it is loud, so equal temperament's fourteen falls outside it — while the fifth's two cents fall inside. The consonances a temperament leaves nearly alone are exactly the ones that stay single sounds.
A ghost bass an octave lower needs notes twice as long
A scale played in just thirds has a bass underneath it that nobody plays — the difference tones of its thirds spell a diatonic line. Every essay on that bass has held its intervals still. A moving passage gives the bass a new pitch every note, and a low pitch is not there until it has run a few of its own cycles. With four cycles, a passage in thirds from C4 keeps its bass for 83 per cent of each note at three notes a second and loses it completely below 73 milliseconds a note. An octave down, every number doubles: the passage from C3 has no bass at all in its lowest note at semiquavers, and it is the scale's one Pythagorean third that sets the limit.
The notes name the ghost bass before it has a cycle
A ghost bass that had to wait for four of its own cycles needed 61 milliseconds under a third from C4, and so vanished from fast passages. A pitch mechanism fitting the whole object — both notes' partials, which run their cycles many times faster, and the products — names the same bass in five. Seven of the eight thirds of a just scale have their bass for most of every note at any tempo a player reaches. The eighth, the scale's Pythagorean D–F, never has its own: the object hears it as a 6 : 5 and supplies the bass a D a comma lower would give, a semitone above the difference tone, until the difference tone arrives and breaks the fit.
The dynamic chooses which D the scale has
A just C major scale has one third that is not 5 : 4 or 6 : 5 — D–F, a Pythagorean 32 : 27 — and a pitch mechanism fitting the notes' partials hears it as the just minor third a comma away, with that third's bass, B♭1, beneath it. Only the Pythagorean third's own difference tone can contradict that, and it is audible only from 76 dB. So below a forte the ghost line under a scale in just thirds is C, B♭, C, F, G, F, G, C for the whole of every note, and the syntonic comma is resolved by the listener rather than the players; above it, and only in notes longer than 73 milliseconds, the B♭ is taken away.
A tuned seventh chord does not beat; it buzzes
Three four-note chords share a ceiling of 0.87 seconds on how long their partial coincidences last, and nothing in that measure could tell them apart. Their beating can. A chord tuned exactly to one harmonic series is one periodic sound, so no two of its partials can differ by less than the series' fundamental: the tuned dominant seventh has no slow beating at all, where the tempered diminished seventh has 125 beating pairs at the strike. Its roughness is another matter. Tuning removes the beats and changes the roughness by a few per cent, in either direction, and a seventh on its way to 7 : 4 beats more, not less, until it arrives.
A tempered seventh chord already has the tuned one's low note
A dominant seventh tuned 4 : 5 : 6 : 7 is one periodic sound, and its period is a note below the chord that nobody plays. The question left open was whether tuning adds that note. Run through the temporal account of residue pitch, the tempered chord turns out to repeat at the same place, a few cents sharp, at 0.82 of the tuned chord's exactness at the strike and 0.96 a second later. Tuning does not create the low note. It makes it exact, and it gets there by a route on which every step helps, which is not true of the beating.
The octave is counted best over a unison left two and a half cents wide
A firm touch buys a mistuned octave's beats only if the aftersound's drop does not deepen with the strike, and the drop was left as a number to be measured. It has a mechanism, and the mechanism has been known since the essay on three strings: the unison's two coupled modes. Computed from them, the drop does not depend on the strike at all. It depends on how wide the tuner left the unison — sixty-five decibels at a quarter of a cent, twenty at three — and the octave's beats peak, at 6.8, over the same two-and-a-half-cent unison that makes the longest note.
A tuned close seventh chord low on the keyboard flutters at one rate
A dominant seventh tuned 4 : 5 : 6 : 7 in close position repeats exactly at a frequency two octaves below its bass, and below B2 that frequency is too slow to be a pitch. The question left was whether the repeat is heard as a flutter. In every auditory filter the chord reaches, its envelope pulses at that one rate, forty times over the threshold for detecting a fluctuation in the filter where it is strongest. The tempered chord fluctuates too, but a third as deeply and at rates that change from filter to filter. Tuning adds something here rather than sharpening it, and it adds it only within two cents of 7 : 4.
The scale's ii chord borrows the dominant's bass
Heard quietly, the pair D–F of a just C major scale brings the bass of the other D with it — B♭, the bass the 10 : 9 D implies — so the comma is resolved by the listener rather than by the players. Add the A that makes the pair a ii chord and that stops being true. The whole-object fit now hears the chord over G, as the top of a dominant ninth, and it does so because the template prefers simple harmonics to accurate ones; a different bass is heard in each inversion, and at a forte none at all. Only a ii built on the 10 : 9 D has one bass in every voicing and at every dynamic. Played quietly from a fixed scale, I–vi–ii–V–I is heard with the bass line C, F, G, G, C: the ii merged into the chord after it, and the progression home.
The plane of the blow matters only where the unison is clean
A piano string vibrates in two planes, and the one parallel to the soundboard gives even a single string a second, slower decay. A hammer tilted off the vertical feeds it. That was the last way left for a firm touch to cost a tuner beats: if harder blows came down straighter. They would have to straighten by half for every seven decibels, and even then only on a single string or a unison tuned clean. Over a unison left two and a half cents wide, no tilt of the blow reaches the count.
A stiff string slows the fourths and quickens the fifths
Every rate in a bearing plan is computed from whole-number partials, and a piano string's partials are not whole numbers. The correction is usually summarised as 'every real beat is faster than the table'. It is not: stiffness quickens the beat of every narrow interval and slows the beat of every wide one, and on a small upright the tempered fourth stops beating altogether. Both errors push the same way, so a tuner who counts the printed table leaves every interval wide, and a fifth and a fourth counted that way make an octave stretched to the 4:2 type or a little past it.
The fourth–fifth check cannot hear the note it checks
A tuner tests a temperament by sounding the fourth below a note and the fifth above it, inside one octave, and comparing their beats. Both beats run to the same partial of the middle note, so moving that note speeds or slows both together and leaves their difference untouched. The check is a test of the octave, and of one particular octave: the 4:2. Measured with each note's own stiffness, the printed table laid fourth first builds exactly that octave on any piano; laid fifth first it overshoots, and the check pulls it back by a third of a cent.
The thirds and the fourths check different octaves
Every interval counted to its printed beat rate on a stiff string is left wide, by an amount set by the squares of the partial numbers that meet in it. Add the links of a chain and the sum lands on an octave type: a fourth and a fifth make the 4:2, a minor third and a major sixth make the 6:3, and three major thirds come just short of the 6:3. So the two most familiar checks in a bearing are exact tests of two different octaves, and on a stiff piano no octave passes both. Each fails on the other's octave by a beat a second at A3.
The octave that fails both checks least
A tuner who cannot pass both the fourth–fifth check and the third–sixth check settles on an octave that fails them equally, and a listener compares beat rates by ratio. Weighed that way, the compromise sits a ninth of the way from the 4:2 octave to the 6:3 on every note of every piano, because the fourth beats twelve times slower than the minor third and that ratio belongs to equal temperament, not to the strings. On a grand both checks then pass to a fifteen-per-cent ear up to middle C, and above it no octave passes both.
The progression of thirds votes for the bearing, not the octave
Added as a third vote beside the two contiguous checks, the progression of thirds was expected to push a stiff piano's octave wider. It pulls it narrower, because the octave it asks for is not set by the strings at all: it is whatever stretch the bearing already carries, plus an eighth of a cent. In an equal bearing that drags the compromise back onto the 4:2 and costs the top of the bearing its pass; give the bearing a fifth of the octave's own stretch and the third vote falls silent.
A bearing counted correctly is stretched by its route, not its strings
A tuner who sets a temperament octave by counting each fourth and fifth to its printed beat rate leaves every one of them a little wide on a stiff string, and the bearing ends up carrying a stretch nobody chose. Whether that stretch is enough to quiet the progression of thirds across the octave's edge turns out to be the wrong question. The stretch belongs to the order of the plan, not to the piano: one ordinary plan carries five times what the progression needs, another a fraction. And either plan leaves the thirds inside the bearing beating in a zigzag, faster then slower then faster, by up to eighteen per cent a step on a grand — which is why the thirds have to set the bearing rather than check it.
A bearing set by its thirds carries five eighths of its octave
A bearing counted from the printed fourths and fifths leaves its thirds zigzagging round the printed progression and takes whatever stretch its route gives it. Set the other way — every note solved at once so that each major third beats faster than the one below by exactly the printed step — the bearing bends smoothly upward and carries 63 per cent of its octave's own stretch, on a grand, on an upright and on everything between. That is more than three times what the octave's three checks need in order to agree, so following the thirds reconciles them with room to spare. The price is paid by the fourths and fifths, every one of which then beats slow.
A stiff string gives the bearing a comma of its own
The twelve fourths and fifths inside a piano's temperament octave are not twelve checks. Laid end to end they are one closed circle, and on stiff strings their printed rates fail to close it by 2.22 cents. Every disagreement between a bearing's tests follows from that one number: which interval never gets counted decides the stretch, and the zigzag in the thirds is the seam. Spread it round the circle and every fourth and fifth beats nine per cent slow of the table, and the thirds come right without being asked.
One walk round the bearing measures the piano and the tuner together
A tuner who counts twelve fourths and fifths to the printed table and comes home flat has measured something. Divide the closing beat's rate by three and correct the whole table by that share, and the worst interval improves from a hundred per cent off to about twenty, on any piano. It keeps the table with one number. And the number cannot tell a stiff string from a slow count: a tuner counting nine per cent slow gets the right bearing from the wrong table, and one correction removes that luck along with the error.