Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Timekeeper — where it appears

The internal process that decides when the next event is due, separately from the movement that produces it. Splitting timing noise from motor noise is what makes a model of human timing testable against measured performances.

Named by 2 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Where the two accounts part company. The spread of the error between the hands, in milliseconds, against bar number, averaged over 120 seeded runs of each model at 100 bars a minute. With one timekeeper it is flat at about 9 ms after 24 bars; with two it reaches 106 ms and is still climbing, because a random walk has nothing to return to. Measured players hold 3 against 2 inside about 25 ms indefinitely.

One player is not two clocks

Two accounts of a pianist playing three against two, simulated from the same noise. With a timekeeper in each hand the hands drift apart by a hundred milliseconds inside two dozen bars. With one timekeeper they never drift at all. The measurement everybody cites as evidence for a timekeeper turns out to be the same number under both accounts.

rhythm · Polyrhythm Two players, and the correction that keeps them together. The spread of the asynchrony between two players, in milliseconds, against beat number, for 3 correction gains, averaged over 120 seeded runs each. It reaches 120 ms after 64 beats at a gain of 0, 27 ms after 64 beats at a gain of 0.1, 20 ms after 64 beats at a gain of 0.3. With no correction at all the asynchrony is a random walk and grows without bound; with any correction it settles at a fixed spread within a few beats and stays there. Two people cannot share a timekeeper, so the fact that ensembles do not come apart is itself the evidence that they are correcting.

Two players and no clock

Two people cannot share a timekeeper, and two independent ones drift a hundred and twenty milliseconds apart inside a minute. Ensembles do not, so something is correcting — and the measurement everybody reaches for recovers the pair's total responsiveness exactly and cannot tell which of the two is doing it. Four tenths from one player and two tenths each give the identical number.

instruments · Microtiming

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

EntrainmentMotor delayRandom walkMicrotimingPolyrhythmResultant patternTiming deviation

All concepts