Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Harmonic minor — where it appears

The natural minor scale with its seventh degree raised, so that the chord on the fifth degree is major and the gap below the tonic is a semitone. The raise exists to supply a leading note, and it costs an augmented second between the sixth and seventh.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The triads each scale builds on its own degrees. Every chord that can be stacked in thirds on each degree of each scale, with its quality worked out from the intervals the scale actually supplies. The quality of the chord on each degree is a consequence of each scale's own step pattern rather than of a convention.

What a raised seventh is for

The harmonic minor is usually taught as a scale with an odd gap in it. It is better understood as a repair to a single chord — raising the seventh degree turns the dominant triad from minor to major, and everything else about the scale is the bill for that.

scales · Modes What each rule costs, in semitones of extra motion. Each prohibition priced on I – ii – iii – IV as the difference between the cheapest realisation that obeys it and the cheapest realisation of all, averaged over every one of the 144 melodies the progression admits inside an octave. The dearest rule costs 1.27 semitones a melody and the cheapest costs nothing, so the bars run from 1.27 to zero; the notes beside them give the share of melodies that pay nothing, or that cannot obey the rule at all.

What the rules cost

The prohibitions of counterpoint are constraints on a minimisation already computed here, so each one has a price in semitones of extra motion. Priced over every melody a progression admits, most of them turn out to be free, the dearest is not the famous one, and two of them cost no motion at all — they cost tunes.

harmony · Voice-leading The rotations of the diatonic set, brought to one tonic. The same rotations started on the same note rather than on their own, ordered by how many of their degrees are raised. Every step lowers exactly one note by a semitone, and the notes it lowers, in order, are F♯, B, E, A, D, G — which is the chain of fifths read backwards. A rotation is a rotation whatever the scale; the chain is a property of a set generated by a single interval, and it disappears the moment the set is not.

Seven rotations that are not seven modes

Rotate harmonic minor and the result is not a family the way the diatonic modes are a family. Four of its six generic intervals come in three specific sizes rather than two, so a fourth might be four, five or six semitones; three of its seven rotations have no fifth above their own tonic; and four have a tonic inside a tritone. The word mode has been doing two different jobs.

scales · Modes The mixture at which the chain acquires a tonic. Eight turns of i–iv–v–i in A minor, natural throughout, read at every mixture of the two emissions: nought is the original set overlap against the triad on each degree, one is the measured probe-tone profile rotated to each candidate key. The blocks along the top are the name the model gives, the line below is how far ahead of its best rival that name is. Below a mixture of 0.55 every bar is called C major, which is the collection and not the key; at and above it every bar is called A minor. The margin collapses to 0.33 bits at the crossing and recovers to 4.56 — higher than the 3.38 it started at, because a profile has an opinion about this passage and an overlap does not.

A tonic bought with the function

Putting the measured probe-tone profile inside the ordered key-finder is one term, and it does what was predicted: the natural-minor passage is named A minor at every bar instead of C major. It also does two things nobody predicted. It renames a scheme that has been read in the wrong key at every bar since the day it was written, and it destroys the chord's function while it is buying the key.

harmony · Key-relations

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Melodic minorLeading noteChord qualityContrary motionCounterpointDominantInterval patternKey-findingKey-relationsModePart-writingPitch-class profile

All concepts