Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Contrary motion — where it appears

Two voices moving in opposite directions at the same time. It is the cheapest way to avoid the parallel intervals counterpoint forbids, and it also keeps two lines perceptually separate, which is a different reason for the same rule.

Named by 3 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

How far the voices have to move. Three chord changes with their voices joined by the assignment that moves the least in total. The distance is computed over every way of pairing the notes, so a change that shares two of its three notes shows as two flat lines.

The shortest move, which is what a chord change is

Between any two chords there is an assignment of voices that moves the least. Compute it and the changes that composers actually use turn out to be the short ones.

harmony · Voice-leading Which partials two notes have in common. The first 12 partials of a note and of the note an interval above it, on a logarithmic frequency axis, with every partial of the upper tone that lands on one of the lower marked. octave: 12 of 12, fifth: 6 of 12, fourth: 4 of 12, major third: 3 of 12, minor third: 2 of 12, minor second: 0 of 12. Sharing partials is what fusion is: two voices whose spectra mostly coincide stop being heard as two voices, which is a measurable property of the interval rather than a matter of taste.

Two voices that stop being two

The ban on parallel fifths is the most famous rule in Western music and it is usually taught as taste. It is not taste. At an octave the upper voice contributes no frequency the lower one did not already have, at a fifth it contributes half of them, and the number can be counted — which turns a prohibition into a measurement.

harmony · Voice-leading What each rule costs, in semitones of extra motion. Each prohibition priced on I – ii – iii – IV as the difference between the cheapest realisation that obeys it and the cheapest realisation of all, averaged over every one of the 144 melodies the progression admits inside an octave. The dearest rule costs 1.27 semitones a melody and the cheapest costs nothing, so the bars run from 1.27 to zero; the notes beside them give the share of melodies that pay nothing, or that cannot obey the rule at all.

What the rules cost

The prohibitions of counterpoint are constraints on a minimisation already computed here, so each one has a price in semitones of extra motion. Priced over every melody a progression admits, most of them turn out to be free, the dearest is not the famous one, and two of them cost no motion at all — they cost tunes.

harmony · Voice-leading

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Voice-leadingCounterpointCommon-toneFusionHarmonic minorLeading noteNeo-Riemannian transformationParsimonyPart-writingPartial

All concepts