Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Series

The triad — the series

9 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Chords as stacked intervals. Each of 4 chords — major, minor, diminished, augmented — drawn as the semitone distances above its root, with the nearest simple frequency ratio beside each note where the 5-limit table has one. Where the chords are triads they differ only in the size of the two stacked thirds, and that difference is the whole of their character.

    Three notes at once, and why these three

    A triad is two thirds stacked, and the four ways of stacking them behave completely differently. The difference is entirely in whether the resulting ratios are simple.

    part 1 · harmony
  2. Every interval, and what it becomes when it is turned over. Each interval within the octave paired with its inversion — the interval left when the lower note is raised by an octave. The two always add to twelve semitones, so exactly one interval can be its own inversion, and it is the one at six.

    The interval that inverts to itself

    Six is the only number that divides twelve into two equal halves, so the tritone is the only interval unchanged by being turned over. That symmetry is not a curiosity — it is why one tritone belongs to two dominant chords, and why they resolve to keys a tritone apart.

    part 2 · harmony
  3. All 55 chords of 3 notes, on both counts. Every 3-note subset of the twelve pitch classes containing the root — 55 of them — with summed Plomp–Levelt roughness on a string spectrum across, and the largest whole number needed to write the chord in just intonation up. The smoothest is 0–5–10, 15:20:27, which is stacked fourths. The simplest is 0–5–9, 3:4:5, which is the major triad. Exactly one chord is in the best 18% on both axes: 3:4:5, the major triad.

    Three is the largest agreeable number

    Take every chord of every size that can be built from the twelve, score each one for roughness and for the size of the whole numbers it needs, and ask how many are good on both counts. At two notes the answer is one. At three notes it is still one. At four it is eight, and the question stops having an answer.

    part 3 · intervals
  4. Every voicing of a second-inversion major triad, least rough first. All 27 arrangements of the same three pitch classes within 3 octaves from 131 Hz, scored for roughness. The best is spaced 19 then 9 semitones — wide below, close above — and the worst is the chord in close position at the bottom of the range, 7.6 times rougher with exactly the same notes in it.

    The inversion that cannot end a phrase

    Three positions of one triad, three measurements, and the practice contradicted at every turn. The second inversion is the smoothest of the three by roughness, the best explained of the three by a virtual-pitch model, and the one that three centuries of practice will not let a phrase end on. What forbids it is a rule about a two-voice skeleton.

    part 4 · intervals
  5. a major triad, C–E–G. The partials are at 261.6, 329.6, 392.0 Hz. Each row is a harmonic series they are consistent with to within 30 cents: the filled dots are the partials in their assigned slots and the open dots are slots the series predicts that nothing occupies. There are 2 such series with harmonic numbers up to 16, the best fitting them to 10.1 cents with a fundamental of 65.54 Hz and no unoccupied slot. The rest sit at one half of it and their arithmetic is exactly as exact; what separates them is the count of empty slots, which is why a residue pitch built from few partials is reported an octave out by a minority of listeners and not by the rest.

    The root an ear supplies

    A major triad's notes fit 4:5:6 with nothing missing and a fundamental two octaves below the bass. A minor triad's fit two different series with two different answers a major sixth apart, and the model cannot choose between them. The ambiguity theorists argued about for two centuries is a computable quantity, and the spectrum invented to remove it is one no object produces.

    part 5 · intervals
  6. The same intervals, played higher and higher. Sensory roughness for four fixed intervals as the pair is transposed up five octaves, computed from the same Plomp–Levelt model as the dissonance curve. Every one of them falls as it rises, and the small intervals fall furthest — so how consonant an interval is depends on where it is played, not only on what it is.

    A chord is a register

    The same three pitch classes are five times rougher at the bottom of a piano than in the middle, and the arrangement that minimises the roughness over a low bass turns out to be the bass's own fifth and sixth partials. The orchestration rule about low thirds is not a convention. It falls out of the width of a critical band, exactly.

    part 6 · intervals
  7. Every 3-note stack of one interval. Each chord built by repeating a single interval 2 times from the root, scored for summed roughness on a string spectrum and asked whether one low fundamental accounts for all its notes within 30 cents. 8 of the 11 are smoother than the major triad, which scores 0.288: stacked major thirds (an augmented triad) at 0.279, stacked fourths at 0.218, stacked tritones at 0.144, stacked fifths at 0.140. And 3 of them have no fundamental at all — stacked minor sixths, stacked major sixths, stacked major sevenths — meaning no series of harmonics up to the 16th accounts for their notes to within a 30-cent tolerance.

    A stack that is not thirds

    Build every chord that repeats a single interval and score them all. Eight of the eleven three-note stacks are smoother than the major triad; the four-note stack of fourths is smoother than a dominant seventh by a third and has no fundamental any matcher can find. Two absences, both computable, and both are exactly what the chord was adopted for.

    part 7 · harmony
  8. What a spread costs a chord. a major triad of 3 notes lasting 600 ms each, with the onsets spread by up to 320 ms. The upper line is the share of each note's length during which every note is sounding; the lower is the chord's roughness weighted by that share, since roughness is a property of two partials sounding at the same time. At a spread of 30 ms — the asynchrony at which a mistimed partial stops belonging to its note — the chord is still 89 per cent simultaneous. It stops being simultaneous at all at 300 ms, which is where the last note arrives after the first has finished.

    The chord that is not played at once

    Every chord until now starts its notes at the same instant, and no figure ever set the asynchrony to anything else. A spread chord is not a defective simultaneity: at forty milliseconds a triad of half-second notes is still eighty-seven per cent simultaneous, so it carries almost all its roughness, and it stops being a chord at all only when the last note arrives after the first has finished. What none of this can explain is the one thing every keyboard player knows — that a chord is rolled upward. The masking asymmetry that ought to explain it is 2.4 decibels at a close voicing, which is not enough.

    part 8 · intervals
  9. Which note a chord would rather have twice. Every complete four-part voicing of each chord inside the SATB ranges, grouped by which member sounds twice and scored for roughness — 480 voicings for a triad. The order for a major triad is root < fifth < third, which is the rule every part-writing treatise states. For a minor triad it is fifth < root < third, which is not. The numbers printed under each bar are the mean error, in cents, with which the four sounding notes fit a single harmonic series, and that measure separates the three far more sharply than roughness does.

    The note that sounds twice

    A triad has three notes and a four-part texture has four voices, so one note is doubled — and the voicing model used here leaves the choice free because the rules have an opinion about it. Asked properly, the arithmetic agrees with the treatises for the first time in nine essays: root, then fifth, then third. For a minor triad it does not agree, and for a symmetric chord it correctly has nothing to say.

    part 9 · intervals

All series