Consonance — the series · Acoustics & Music Theory

Two tones in the ratio 3 to 2. Two sine tones whose frequencies are in the ratio 3 to 2, and their sum. The combined pattern repeats every time both waves return to the start together, which for a simple ratio is soon — here after 2 cycles of the lower tone and 3 of the upper.

Two notes and a ratio, which is the whole of consonance

Sound two tones together and the pair either settles or does not. What decides it is the ratio of their frequencies, and the rule is that simpler ratios settle — which is two and a half thousand years old and still not quite an explanation.

part 1 · intervals

Roughness across an octave. Sensory dissonance between two complex tones as the upper one is swept through an octave, computed by summing the roughness between every pair of their partials. Nothing here is placed by hand. The wells this spectrum produces sit on 4/3, on 3/2, on 5/3, found by scanning the curve rather than by marking them. And the tempered minor third sits 198 cents below the nearest well, and the tempered major third sits 98 cents below the nearest well, which is a real feature of this model and not a defect of the drawing.

Roughness can be computed, and the answer looks like a scale

Feed two spectra into a model of how nearby frequencies interfere, sweep one past the other, and the curve that comes out has dips exactly where the consonant intervals are. Nobody put them there.

part 2 · intervals

The critical band, measured in semitones. The width of the ear's frequency-analysis band at each pitch, converted from hertz into semitones. Two intervals drawn as horizontal lines cross the curves: below the crossing the interval fits inside one band and its notes are not resolved from each other, and above it they are.

A third is rougher in the bass

Consonance is usually presented as a property an interval has. It is not. The same major third is muddy two octaves below middle C and clean two octaves above it, the ratio never changed, and the frequency where it stops being muddy can be solved for.

part 3 · intervals

Two models of consonance, and where they disagree. Every chord scored twice: horizontally by summed Plomp–Levelt roughness, vertically by the largest integer needed to write it as members of one harmonic series. Both are supposed to be measuring consonance and both are computed here from the chord itself. They correlate, but not tightly enough to be the same claim, and the chords furthest from the diagonal are the ones any experiment has to be run on.

Consonance is half learned, and this is the half

This site's founding claim is that consonance is small whole numbers. Two computable models say so and they disagree about which chords — which is already awkward. The cross-cultural evidence is worse: listeners with little exposure to Western music discriminate roughness exactly as anyone does, match octaves exactly as anyone does, and rate consonant and dissonant chords as equally pleasant.

part 4 · perception

Three spectra, and where each one's consonances fall. The positions of the roughness minima for 3 partial sets, over 12 semitones from the same fundamental, found by scanning each curve rather than by marking them. A harmonic tone — 498 cents at 3.1 per cent prominence, 702 cents at 37.1 per cent prominence, 884 cents at 6.2 per cent prominence. Partials stretched by 2.1 per octave — 533 cents at 3.7 per cent prominence, 751 cents at 40.1 per cent prominence, 947 cents at 7.3 per cent prominence. A bar's partials — 1, 2.76, 5.40, 8.93 — 694 cents at 5.6 per cent prominence, 870 cents at 14.2 per cent prominence, 982 cents at 1.0 per cent prominence, 1166 cents at 14.7 per cent prominence. The minima are computed by the same well-finder the dissonance curve uses, which requires a minimum to have one per cent of the curve's range on both sides of it before it counts.

A spectrum chooses its own scale

The roughness curve's dips are always described as landing on the small whole numbers. They do not land on numbers. They land where partials coincide, and stretching a spectrum by seven per cent moves every one of them by exactly seven per cent — so the scale a set of intervals belongs to is a property of the instrument's spectrum rather than of arithmetic.

part 5 · intervals

The least rough 7 notes of the twelve, at 262 Hz. Every 7-note selection from the twelve that contains C, scored for total Plomp–Levelt roughness at a root of 262 Hz, ranked. The best 8 are shown with the spread between them. The major scale ranks 5 of 462; the first selection that is a mode of the diatonic set ranks 1. Change the root and the ranking changes, because roughness is a fact about frequencies and a scale is not.

Roughness cannot choose a scale

Score all four hundred and sixty-two seven-note selections from the twelve for roughness and the answer at middle C is a mode of the diatonic set, first out of four hundred and sixty-two. Ask the same question an octave lower and the same selection ranks a hundred and forty-first. The model is not wrong; it is answering a question about frequencies, and a scale is not one.

part 6 · intervals

Cycles of roughness completed in 125 milliseconds. For each interval and each register, how many cycles of its own beating fit inside a note 125 milliseconds long. Cells at or above 4 cycles are the ones a listener has time to hear as rough; the pattern runs the opposite way from roughness itself, which is largest in the bass. A short dissonance low down is the case where the two disagree.

A dissonance has to last

Roughness is a fluctuation, and a fluctuation needs cycles. A minor second at the bottom of a cello fluctuates thirty-three times a second, so a semiquaver holds four of them and a demisemiquaver holds two — which turns the counterpoint rule that a dissonance may pass if it is short into a number, and puts that number at about seventy milliseconds through most of the range, once the pairs beating too slowly to be roughness at all are taken out of the average.

part 7 · intervals

Where to put the third

Take three pitch classes, four octaves to put them in, and score all twenty-seven arrangements. The smoothest is root, fifth an octave up, third two octaves up — which is partials one, three and five of the harmonic series — and the roughest, at every register tried, is the chord in close root position at the bottom of the range. Every orchestration manual states that rule and none of them derives it.

part 8 · harmony

The thirteen intervals at C4, ordered by roughness, against Fux's species, 1725. Every interval within an octave above 262 Hz, ordered by the Plomp–Levelt roughness of a string spectrum — from 0.0029 for the unison to 0.2635 for the minor second — beside whether Fux's species, 1725 counts it a consonance and how many of the thirteen may follow it under that rule set. The best single threshold on roughness misclassifies 2 of the thirteen, among them the major third and the minor third, and the gap it falls in is 4.2 per cent of the roughness either side of it.

A dissonance is what has to be resolved

The perfect fourth is a consonance between two upper voices and a dissonance against the bass, and the same three notes are involved either way. Score both arrangements with the roughness model and the one the rules call a dissonance comes out thirty per cent smoother. Whatever the rule is tracking, it is not the sound.

part 9 · harmony

Roughness and loudness of one interval against level. A minor third on C4 evaluated at every level from 20 to 100 dB SPL per note, with both quantities drawn relative to their own value at 60 dB. Roughness is the Plomp–Levelt sum over the partials that are above ISO 226's threshold at that level; loudness is the same partials in sones. Between 50 and 95 dB the interval grows 3.2 × 10⁴ times rougher and 24.9 times louder, so roughness grows like loudness raised to the power 3.2.

The same chord is harsher when it is louder

Every roughness number so far was computed at a level nobody stated. Roughness is the product of two partial amplitudes, so it is quadratic in pressure, while loudness is compressive — which makes a minor third at middle C thirty-two thousand times rougher at fortissimo than at pianissimo and only twenty-five times louder. A chord has no single consonance to report.

part 10 · intervals