Generator

The least rough 7 notes of the twelve, at 262 Hz

Every 7-note selection from the twelve that contains C, scored for total Plomp–Levelt roughness at a root of 262 Hz, ranked. The best 8 are shown with the spread between them. The major scale ranks 5 of 462; the first selection that is a mode of the diatonic set ranks 1. Change the root and the ranking changes, because roughness is a fact about frequencies and a scale is not.

Drawn above with its standard settings, which is almost never how an essay draws it: an essay states the numbers it is arguing about, so the figure a reader meets there is about that argument rather than about the drawing in general. Every option a placement passes is checked against the ones this function actually reads, because an option it does not read is silently ignored and the figure quietly draws what is above instead.

It makes a noise. 20 of its 20 placements carry sound, built from the same numbers as the drawing, offering these buttons: The 7 notes this scan highlights, one after another, The least rough 7, together, The major scale, together, The roughest 7, together, The same notes all at once, which is where the roughness being scanned is.

Called by 4 essays

the blast radius of changing it

Roughness cannot choose a scale

Score all four hundred and sixty-two seven-note selections from the twelve for roughness and the answer at middle C is a mode of the diatonic set, first out of four hundred and sixty-two. Ask the same question an octave lower and the same selection ranks a hundred and forty-first. The model is not wrong; it is answering a question about frequencies, and a scale is not one.

intervals · Consonance

The 7-note sets in which every interval occurs a different number of times. Each set of 7 notes containing C whose six interval counts are all different, with the counts printed. Every one of them is a rotation of one of two shapes, and only one of the two has steps a scale could use — the other is a run of semitones with the gap at the end.

Every interval a different number of times

Count the intervals inside a major scale and the six answers are 2, 5, 4, 3, 6 and 1 — six different numbers, no two alike. That is not decoration. It means the number of notes a key shares with a transposition of itself identifies the distance uniquely, so a listener who can only count common tones can still tell exactly how far a modulation went.

scales · The diatonic set

Four properties, ten sizes, one survivor. Every subset of the twelve pitch classes, counted by shape, at each size from two notes to eleven, and how many shapes of each size have each property. Exactly one shape in the whole table has all four at once: the 7-note set with steps 1221222, which is the diatonic scale.

Why seven

Four properties, each shared with some other set. Run all four over every subset of the twelve, at every size from two notes to eleven — three hundred and forty-nine shapes in all — and exactly one has all four at once. It is the diatonic set, and it is the only survivor in the whole twelve-note universe.

scales · The diatonic set

The same census, in every universe from four to thirty. How many sets have all four properties, in a universe of n equal steps. None at all when n is two more than a multiple of four — 6, 10, 14, 18, 22, 26, 30 — exactly one when n is a multiple of four, and exactly two when n is odd. The multiples of four each have their survivor at n/2 + 1 notes generated by n/2 − 1 steps, so twelve's seven notes generated by the fifth is the general answer with n put at twelve rather than a fact about twelve.

Every universe has one, or none

Run the census that found the diatonic set in a universe of nineteen equal steps, or twenty-four, or fifty-three. The answer is completely regular and nobody appears to have written it down — none at all when the universe is two more than a multiple of four, exactly one when it is a multiple of four, and exactly two when it is odd.

tuning · The diatonic set

All figures · What can be heard