Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Generator

The major scale as a cycle

The twelve semitones drawn as a cycle, with the notes of the scale filled in. The gaps between filled positions are the step pattern, and reading them round the circle is what makes the scale's asymmetry obvious.
The major scale as a cycle. The twelve semitones drawn as a cycle, with the notes of the scale filled in. The gaps between filled positions are the step pattern, and reading them round the circle is what makes the scale's asymmetry obvious.

Drawn above with its standard settings, which is almost never how an essay draws it: an essay states the numbers it is arguing about, so the figure a reader meets there is about that argument rather than about the drawing in general. Every option a placement passes is checked against the ones this function actually reads, because an option it does not read is silently ignored and the figure quietly draws what is above instead.

It makes a noise. 21 of its 21 placements carry sound, built from the same numbers as the drawing, offering these buttons: All at once, Up the scale.

Called by 8 essays

the blast radius of changing it

The major scale as a cycle. The twelve semitones drawn as a cycle, with the notes of the scale filled in. The gaps between filled positions are the step pattern, and reading them round the circle is what makes the scale's asymmetry obvious.

Seven of the twelve, chosen unevenly

A major scale is a selection of seven positions out of twelve, and the selection is lopsided on purpose. The two semitones sit where they do because an even choice would destroy the thing that makes a scale usable.

scales · The diatonic set The seven modes, brightest first. The same seven pitch classes started on each of its degrees in turn, ordered by how many of their notes are raised. Each row differs from the one below it by exactly one note, and that note moves down one semitone each time.

The same seven, started later

A mode is not a new scale. It is the same seven notes with a different one treated as home, and the entire change in character comes from reassigning which degree the semitones fall next to.

scales · Modes Stopping the chain of fifths at every length. The chain of fifths taken two notes at a time, three, four and so on, with each collection folded into a single octave. The smallest gap in the collection is measured at every stage: it is two semitones until the sixth note arrives, and then it is one. Five is as far as the chain goes without producing a semitone.

Five notes, and no semitones

The five black keys sound acceptable in any combination, in any order, over almost any bass note. That is not mysticism and not luck — five is the longest a chain of fifths can run before it produces a semitone, and the number is derived rather than chosen.

scales · The diatonic set The triads each scale builds on its own degrees. Every chord that can be stacked in thirds on each degree of each scale, with its quality worked out from the intervals the scale actually supplies. The quality of the chord on each degree is a consequence of each scale's own step pattern rather than of a convention.

What a raised seventh is for

The harmonic minor is usually taught as a scale with an odd gap in it. It is better understood as a repair to a single chord — raising the seventh degree turns the dominant triad from minor to major, and everything else about the scale is the bill for that.

scales · Modes The seven modes, brightest first. The same seven pitch classes started on each of its degrees in turn, ordered by how many of their notes are raised. Each row differs from the one below it by exactly one note, and that note moves down one semitone each time.

Nothing in the census knows which note is home

All four properties six earlier essays are about are invariant under rotation and transposition — one property tuple over all eighty-four rotations and transpositions of the diatonic set. So the census that separates 349 shapes cannot separate a major scale from its own Aeolian mode, and everything that makes one note a tonic is outside it.

scales · The diatonic set The price of a tonic. Every note of Dorian is given the same duration except its tonic, which is lengthened; the horizontal axis is the share of the total that goes to it. The key-finder answers with the parent key until 25.0 per cent of the time is spent on the modal tonic, and with D minor above it. At the left-hand edge every note has equal weight, which is the pitch-class set itself — and with every weight identical the correlation is not merely low but undefined, because a flat histogram has no variance to correlate with anything.

What a tonic costs in seconds

The standard key-finding algorithm cannot be run on a pitch-class set at all — a flat histogram has no variance and the correlation is undefined. Give it durations and it answers with the parent key for all seven modes identically, and it takes between 15.8 and 30.0 per cent of the total time spent on one note before it names that note instead.

perception · Modes The rotations of the diatonic set, brought to one tonic. The same rotations started on the same note rather than on their own, ordered by how many of their degrees are raised. Every step lowers exactly one note by a semitone, and the notes it lowers, in order, are F♯, B, E, A, D, G — which is the chain of fifths read backwards. A rotation is a rotation whatever the scale; the chain is a property of a set generated by a single interval, and it disappears the moment the set is not.

Parallel and relative are two different maps

Bring the seven modes to one tonic and order them by brightness, and each step lowers exactly one note by a semitone — and the notes it lowers, in order, are F♯, B, E, A, D, G, the chain of fifths read backwards. Do the same to harmonic minor's rotations and each step moves two, three or four notes at once. The famous chain belongs to the generator, not to rotation.

scales · Modes A model that cannot say two keys does not say it is unsure. I – IV – V – I played in C major and in a second major key at the same time, with the second key moved round the circle of fifths. For each separation: the correlation the standard key-finder gives its single best answer, and the correlation reached by the best PAIR of key profiles — a hypothesis the finder does not have. The pair recovers both keys that are sounding at every separation, 7 of 7. The single answer names neither of them at 4 of the 7, and its confidence does not fall when it is wrong: at four steps apart it reports E minor at r = 0.886, against 0.959 for the same progression in one key.

Two keys at once

Every key figure so far assumes one key is sounding, and the standard key-finder has no value it can return that means two. Play one progression in C and the same progression a major third away at the same time, and the model does not report uncertainty: it reports E minor, at a correlation of 0.886, against 0.959 for the same progression in one key. It is as confident as it ever is, and neither key it names is being played. Give it the missing hypothesis — pairs of key profiles rather than single ones — and it recovers both keys at every separation, all seven of seven.

harmony · Key-relations

All figures · What can be heard