Generator

Three answers to how finely a pitch can be heard — the pitch resolution generator

Three resolutions across five octaves, on a logarithmic scale of cents. Two notes one after the other are told apart at 4.0 cents at A440 and 8.6 cents three octaves down. Whether a melodic interval is in tune is a judgement an order of magnitude coarser, 25 to 50 cents. And two notes held a fifth apart are heard to beat once every 2 seconds at 1.31 cents, which is finer than either. The horizontal lines are the step sizes of the equal divisions that have been built: 12 at 100.0 cents, 24 at 50.0 cents, 53 at 22.6 cents, 72 at 16.7 cents. Every one of them is coarser than discrimination and finer than melodic judgement.

Three answers to how finely a pitch can be heard. Three resolutions across five octaves, on a logarithmic scale of cents. Two notes one after the other are told apart at 4.0 cents at A440 and 8.6 cents three octaves down. Whether a melodic interval is in tune is a judgement an order of magnitude coarser, 25 to 50 cents. And two notes held a fifth apart are heard to beat once every 2 seconds at 1.31 cents, which is finer than either. The horizontal lines are the step sizes of the equal divisions that have been built: 12 at 100.0 cents, 24 at 50.0 cents, 53 at 22.6 cents, 72 at 16.7 cents. Every one of them is coarser than discrimination and finer than melodic judgement.

Drawn above with its standard settings, which is almost never how an essay draws it: an essay states the numbers it is arguing about, so the figure a reader meets there is about that argument rather than about the drawing in general. Every option a placement passes is checked against the ones this function actually reads, because an option it does not read is silently ignored and the figure quietly draws what is above instead.

It makes a noise. 8 of its 8 placements carry sound, built from the same numbers as the drawing, offering these buttons: A fifth mistuned by 1.31 cents, held: one beat in 2 seconds, which is finer still, Two tones 25 cents apart, which is where a melodic interval starts to be a different interval, Two tones 4.0 cents apart, one after the other: the smallest difference a listener can name.

Called by 4 essays

the blast radius of changing it

Three answers to how finely a pitch can be heard

Two notes one after the other are told apart at about four cents at A440. Whether a melodic interval is in tune is a judgement an order of magnitude coarser. And two notes held together are heard to beat at a third of a cent, because the question is answered by counting rather than by hearing pitch at all. Every equal division ever built sits between the coarsest and the finest.

perception · Beyond twelve

How finely a fifth can be heard, against how fast it goes by. The smallest audible mistuning of a melodic fifth above 440 hertz, against how long each of its two notes lasts. The lower solid line is one note's own limen; the upper one is the interval's, larger because two independent errors add in quadrature. A tenth of a second gives 23.5 cents against the note's own 19.6, the floor for long notes is 5.4, and the syntonic comma is not cleared until each note lasts 111 milliseconds. The dotted line at 1.31 cents is the same interval heard as a simultaneity, where partials 3 and 2 coincide at 1320 hertz and one beat every 2 seconds can be counted there.

An interval is two errors

Two notes in succession are two pitch estimates, and what a listener judges is their difference — so a melodic interval is heard less finely than either of the notes in it. At a semiquaver the limen is nineteen cents, which lands inside a published range long quoted from the literature and never derived. Sounded together instead of one after the other, the same interval is judged eighteen times more finely.

intervals · Pitch-acuity

Three ways a category boundary could move, and how far each moves it. The predicted shift of one boundary against how strong the context is, for three mechanisms. Expectation alone — a listener who thinks one category 20 times more likely than the other — moves the optimal boundary by σ²·ln(odds)/Δ, which with the eleven-cent noise used here is 2.8 cents at ten to one and 3.6 at 20. Re-learning the centres from a context 30 cents away moves it by half of that, 15 cents. Selective adaptation moves it the OTHER way. The two directions are what an experiment would separate, and no absolute calibration is needed to do it.

The boundary that barely moves

Every identification figure here has fixed category centres, and the essay before this one ended by admitting that real boundaries are supposed to move with context. Three mechanisms could move one, and their predictions are an order of magnitude apart and in two different directions. Expectation on its own — a listener who thinks one interval twenty times more likely than the other — is worth three and a half cents.

perception · Categorical-hearing

Every resolution claim here, against the number it rests on. How many equal steps of the octave can be named at 95 per cent accuracy, against the internal noise the model gives a listener. The laboratory value this collection quotes everywhere is 11 cents, which gives 6 nameable categories — the "about seven per octave" every claim here has been repeating. The laboratory measures it on isolated intervals and music never presents one, so the effective value inside a piece is smaller by an amount nobody has measured: at 4 cents it is 18, which is the chromatic scale, and the conclusion changes from "the ear has fewer boxes than the notation" to "it has exactly as many". Nothing here measures it. This is what it is worth if it moves.

The number every claim here has been quoting

Sigma is the internal noise a listener's pitch judgements carry, it is measured in a laboratory on isolated intervals, and music never presents an isolated interval. Every resolution claim here rests on the laboratory value. Sweep it and the headline finding moves: at eleven cents the ear has about six nameable categories per octave, and at six it has twelve — which is the chromatic scale, and turns 'the ear has fewer boxes than the notation' into 'it has exactly as many'.

scales · Categorical-hearing

All figures · What can be heard