Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Meantone — where it appears

A tuning that narrows every fifth by the same fraction of a syntonic comma, of which the quarter-comma form makes the major third exactly pure. Its chain does not close, so a major third and a diminished fourth are two pitches forty-one cents apart.

Named by 6 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

How far each system sits from equal temperament. Deviation from equal temperament, in cents, for each degree of the chromatic scale. Zero is equal temperament by definition; the just major third is about fourteen cents flat of it and the Pythagorean major third about eight cents sharp.

Where to hide the comma, which is the only real question

Four tuning systems, four different places to put an error that cannot be removed. Each one is coherent, each was standard somewhere, and the choice between them decided what music could be written.

tuning · The comma Every keyboard temperament before 1800, on one line. The fifth's departure from pure against the major third's, for a temperament that narrows every fifth by the same amount. The relation is a straight line — a third is four fifths — so the systems that are usually presented as rival schemes are points on one continuum, and the parameter that indexes them is a single number.

A fraction of a comma

The tuning systems of three centuries are usually presented as rival schemes with names and dates. They are points on a line. Narrow every fifth by the same fraction of a comma and both errors that matter are linear in that fraction — and the system named as the break with the tradition turns out to be a member of it, at one part in eleven.

tuning · The comma The chain of fifths in quarter-comma meantone. The fifths laid end to end as the chain they are. The bar under each shows how far that fifth departs from a pure three-to-two, and one of them — G♯ to D♯, the 12th link, where the chain is forced to close — is the wolf, at 35.7 cents.

The same distance, under two names

Four hundred cents is a major third or a diminished fourth, and on a keyboard nothing in the sound distinguishes them. An earlier essay was about the boundary between two categories; this is about two categories at one acoustic value, and the surprise is where the ambiguity comes from. In quarter-comma meantone a major third is 386 cents and a diminished fourth is 427 — two names, two pitches, forty-one cents apart. Equal temperament collapsed them, and what a listener now supplies from context used to be in the sound.

intervals · Categorical hearing Where the two spellings meet, and where they cross. G♯ minus A♭ against the fraction of a comma each fifth is narrowed by — twelve fifths against seven octaves, and nothing else in the calculation. In Pythagorean tuning G♯ is 23.46 cents ABOVE A♭; in quarter-comma meantone it is 41.06 cents BELOW it; the two spellings coincide at 0.09090 of a comma, which is what equal temperament is. A page that distinguishes the two names is exact in every tuning on this line except one point on it, and at that point it is wrong by 0.0014 cents rather than by nothing, because one eleventh is not quite the crossing.

Two names for one key

A keyboard has one key between G and A and the page has two names for it. That looks like redundancy and it is not: the two names are twelve fifths apart on a chain, and in every tuning anybody played before the nineteenth century they are two different pitches. The size of the difference is twelve fifths against seven octaves and nothing else — twenty-three cents one way in Pythagorean, forty-one the other way in meantone, and zero at exactly one point in between.

tuning · Notation A tempered major third and its own ghost are not one sound. The multiple of the implied fundamental that each reading names, against how far the upper note is tempered from the just major third, at 55 and 80 dB. At 55 dB the notes and products together name the fundamental from −9.0 cents to +8.5 cents and no template at all outside that; the products alone name 3 times it and go on naming very nearly that across the whole range. At 80 dB the notes and products together name the fundamental from −2.0 cents to +2.0 cents and no template at all outside that; the products alone name 1 times it and go on naming very nearly that across the whole range. Equal temperament's major third is +13.7 cents, which is outside the window at both dynamics. The notes alone name the fundamental throughout, because tempering moves every partial of the upper note by the same amount and a template can follow it.

A tempered third cannot be one sound with its own ghost

The essay before this one fitted one harmonic template to a just third's played partials and the products of those partials together, and it worked at every dynamic. Tempered, it does not work at all — and not by naming a different note. There is no template. The lower note's partials sit exactly on their harmonics, the upper note's are every one fourteen cents out, and the products are twenty-three cents out the other way, a span of thirty-seven cents across a tolerance of thirty. The window is nine cents wide when the third is soft and two when it is loud, so equal temperament's fourteen falls outside it — while the fifth's two cents fall inside. The consonances a temperament leaves nearly alone are exactly the ones that stay single sounds.

intervals · Combination tone A meantone keyboard is a stretch of the chain of fifths, and every split key lengthens it by one place at an end. 14 keys hold the positions from A♭ to D♯. That is 10 major and 10 minor triads; major keys E♭, B♭, F, C, G, D, A, E; minor keys with a raised leading note C, G, D, A, E.

A split key buys one of everything, and two buy C and E

An organ builder with money for two extra keys could have put them anywhere, and the arithmetic of triads cannot say where. On a meantone keyboard every added key buys exactly one major triad, one minor triad, one major key and one minor key, wherever it goes. So the count is no guide, and the choice was about which keys. The two accidentals most often divided, G♯/A♭ and D♯/E♭, are one on each side of the chain, and they are exactly what completes the minor keys on C and E. What they buy by the roughness sum is seven per cent.

tuning · Split keys

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

EnharmonicEqual temperamentJust intonationTemperamentChain of fifthsLesser diesisNotationSplit keysSyntonic commaCategorical perceptionCentsCombination tone

All concepts