Acoustics & Music Theory
why it sounds like that
Concept

Contour — where it appears

The sequence of signs of a melody's intervals — up, down or the same — with the sizes discarded. It survives transposition, retuning and a change of instrument, which is why it is what a listener keeps of an unfamiliar tune.

Named by 5 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Ode to Joy as a path. Ode to Joy plotted as 30 notes against the 8 scale degrees it uses, one column per note. Its largest melodic interval is 2 semitones and it spans 7; the mean absolute step is 1.24 semitones. Beethoven, Ninth Symphony, finale, 1824 — the theme as first stated, eight bars.

A melody is a walk, not a set

Nine essays here are about which seven of the twelve a scale takes, and every one of them describes a set. A tune is not a set; it is a path across one, and the path is nearly all small steps. That is not a matter of taste. Above about eight notes a second the ear stops being able to hold a large interval and a small one in the same line, and at sixteen the choice disappears altogether — so a fast passage is scalar because a fast passage that leaps is two pieces of music.

scales · Melody How much of the rule a walk with no rule reproduces. Post-skip reversal in 20,000-note random walks with no melodic knowledge of any kind. An unbounded walk reverses after 50.0 per cent of leaps, which is the chance rate and is the check that the measurement is right. Confining it to 12 semitones raises that to 61.3 per cent. Reaching the 70 per cent that corpus studies report needs a central tendency of 0.95 — an almost deterministic pull back toward the middle at the edges of the range. A wall is not enough; there has to be a spring.

The leap that pays itself back

Every melody textbook teaches that a leap should be followed by a step in the opposite direction, and every corpus that has been counted agrees — around seven leaps in ten are answered that way. A random walk with two walls, no memory of the leap and no rule of any kind reverses after 61 per cent of them, and the residue is not a rule either. What is left when the walls are accounted for is a prediction the rule does not make, and it is the prediction that decides between them.

form · Melody The arch is not a preference. Every sequence of 6 notes over 8 scale degrees — 262,144 of them, enumerated rather than sampled — classified by contour, under three constraints. With none, the nine classes are spread. Requiring the sequence to return to its starting degree leaves only the arch, the valley and the flat, at 42.2 per cent each for the first two. Requiring it to begin and end on the LOWEST degree leaves the arch alone, at 99.6 per cent. Nothing here prefers a rise followed by a fall; the constraint is that the melody comes home, and a melody that comes home from below has nowhere to go but up first.

The shape that survives everything else

Throw away a melody's key, its tuning, its instrument and the sizes of its intervals, and what is left is a string of pluses and minuses. That string is what a listener who cannot name a note still has, and it costs 37 per cent of the tune to keep. The arch that melodic shape is famous for is not in it as a preference: enumerate every six-note sequence that begins and ends on the lowest degree it uses and 99.6 per cent of them are arches, because a melody that comes home from below has nowhere to go first but up.

form · Melody The same steps, counted by the clock. The step distribution of Ode to Joy and Twinkle, twinkle counted two ways: once per interval, which is what every earlier figure did, and once weighted by how long the note it leaves is held. The two disagree because a tune's long notes are not distributed evenly over its interval sizes — in Ode to Joy the 2-semitone step is 55.2 per cent of the moves and 60.0 per cent of the time. Which of the two a claim about melodic motion means has never been stated here, and the answer matters most exactly where a tune slows down, which is at the ends of its phrases.

The note that has a length

Every melodic figure so far reads a table where each note is a pair — a pitch and a duration — and throws the second number away. A step between two minims and a step between two quavers have been one event in every histogram it has drawn. Weighting the same statistics by time moves the step distribution by up to seven points, changes forty-four of a hundred and one contour signs, and turns up an off-by-one in the one figure that did use the durations: it took the length of the note arrived at where the time between two onsets is the length of the note left.

rhythm · Melody What a contour costs to remember. A melody of n notes over 8 degrees carries 3 bits a note. Its contour carries fewer, and fewer than the number of distinct contours suggests, because the contours are not equally likely: at 6 notes there are 243 of them but the entropy is 6.59 bits, an effective alphabet of 96. Each further note adds 1.28 bits of contour against three of melody, so the shape keeps a stable 37 per cent of what is there however long the tune.

The part of the tune that is kept

Contour survives transposition, retuning, a change of instrument and a doubling of every interval, and the usual explanation is that it is what a listener retains. That can be counted rather than assumed. A six-note melody over eight degrees carries eighteen bits; its contour carries 6.59 — not the 7.92 the number of distinct shapes suggests, because the shapes are wildly unequal — and the effective alphabet is ninety-six out of two hundred and forty-three. Each further note adds 1.28 bits of shape against three of melody, and at about nine notes a contour is specific enough to pick one tune out of a thousand.

perception · Melody

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Melodic intervalEnumerationNull modelRelative pitchStreamingTemporal coherenceTessituraArchAuditory scene analysisDescription lengthDurationFission boundary

All concepts